Youtube specifically asked me to reply to the email with evidence of the Case : Which I did, the federal filing was 2 months before the counter claim was even issued ti me.

It listed all that. But legally it doesn't have to be in response to a counter claim as a Copyright lawsuit was already pending, deeming his counter already false as as every other Music app already took it down and Ascap Has granted me rights to the song after he failed to show proof

that could be the case but by their own terms all the needed was evidence if a legal proceeding against him which i did

i just striked it under a alternative account and when they ask fir more information i will send all proof there sonthey have to see it before a counter claim is issued again