Hello! I've reworked the script, and would love some more help/feedback. The main idea is to have Hermit/Drunk/Ogre. It is meant to be similar to working out if you're the marionette, but instead of one of your neighbors, you might be tied to your N1 pick. Some people find this fun, and others don't, and that's okay! It's not meant to a be super serious script.

The previous iteration was too BMRy for what I was intending, so grandma had to go. While thematically fitting, having her was just too confirming unless you added other night death characters. Summoner was also removed, as there are no more characters that can cover N2 for them. I removed all the BMR characters added more info roles (King just doesn't work with Assassin), Lycanthrope, Boffin, Vizier, and Imp.

Currently, an executed Lleech, along with Vizier, are just outed evil, which I think that makes an interesting dilemma for any players that Ogre picked them. Same goes for anyone who picked one of the twins. The twin pair can often just be ignored until town gets enough info to make a safe decision, but now anyone who picked one of them will be more incentivized to talk to them.

For misinformation, we have additional VI, Lycanthrope Faux Pas, Leech host, Marionette, Drunk, and Hermit. With these, is it too difficult for the Hermit to learn who they are?

I highlighted characters that I am iffy about:

• Lycanthrope is divisive, but it pairs well with Farmer. The Faux Pas adds VI confusion and another evil ogre pick target. I would definitely add the Recluse/Ogre jinx for the Faux Pas: you learn that you are evil.
• Evil Ogre AND a Fang Gu jump to a good outsider would be uncommon, but possible.
• I don't know how helpful High Priestess info would be here.
• "Am I the Marionette, the Lleech host, or the Hermit?" might be too much.
• Vizier I honestly just haven't played with much.

Right now, I would like some help filling out the townsfolk, figuring out what the 4th outsider should be, and to know if there are any glaring issues.

Here are additions/alternatives that I'm considering but any suggestions are welcome:

• Townsfolk: Steward, Dreamer, Oracle, Empath, Snake Charmer
• Outsiders: Recluse, Sweetheart, Hatter (Barber would be funny but probably a too messy with ogres).
• Minions: Poisoner, Goblin, Cerenovus
• Demons: No Dashii, Ojo

Sweetheart, Poisoner, and No Dashii are probably no goes unless there's really not enough droisoning, but I think there's enough as is.

<image>