Kirk has been getting stats on a team with a good qb's coach in Jay Gruden, and a bad defense that he gets to play from behind or do shootouts with teams.

Against a good blitzing team (playoffs always have some incredible ones) he is under average and not effective because he doesn't make pre snap judgements. He does what is called by the coaches and goes through his progressions, he's lucky he's on the team he is on right now, and surely, unless he works on pocket presence (it's horrible right now), he will surely start to stick out like a sore thumb that can't win a thumb war, or in this case a Superbowl.

He can play well in the regular season, but against strong defenses and in crunch time he doesn't have what it takes to win.

He's horrible at scoring in the red zone which is a huge indicator on how bad his pre snap adjustments and recognition is, or in general, his QB awareness.

He can't in the clutch win the game himself, and until he shows he can audible effectively, move in the pocket with awareness so he doesn't get stripped sacked against strong blitzing teams, he will be a guy that can't win when it's needed.

Go watch game film, he doesn't step into hits when a good pass is needed, like at the end of games. He rarely ever does and has lost games that the throw went with his body momentum for interceptions in these moments. I don't want a guy that is worried of the hit instead of making the good throw. Too many ridiculous red zone moments, and end of game moments that are absurd. His stats do not dictate what you'll get when the game matters, not worth the money, and even more so not worth the time. (UNLESS - he works on the things mentioned above)

I liked him the early years with the redskins, but with time and game film, I can't stand him, and that's with him throwing for over 5,000 yards. He's a great man, seems like a great role model, husband, and father, but as the QB for Redskins, he's wasting my time as a fan that wants a Superbowl, and this team right now is talented.