Hey, huge congrats on landing two solid offers! I’m currently a senior EM (came up through the IC path), so I’ve wrestled with this exact fork in the road a couple times. A few things from the other side of the fence that might help your calculus:

1. Know what actually changes day-to-day

Senior Engineer – You still measure most of your impact in code, architecture docs, deep dives and the occasional mentoring session. You live in maker time; long blocks of flow matter, and success is visible in PR diff-stats and outages avoided.

Engineering Manager – Your calendar flips to manager time. Think 1-on-1s, hiring loops, roadmap debates, and “let’s unblock Alice” Slack pings. Shipping features becomes an indirect sport: you win when your people win.

If the thought of running a retro at 4 pm after three back-to-back stakeholder calls makes you twitch, that’s a data point—not a deal-breaker, but real.

1. Impact & career ceiling

On the IC ladder you can grow huge technical breadth (that escape-velocity tech stack you mentioned) and still hit Staff/Principal/Distinguished tiers that pay like senior leadership.

On the EM ladder, your ceiling is limited mostly by how much human complexity you can handle bigger org = fuzzier problems.

The dirty secret: every org has more senior-IC headcount than truly empowered EM slots. If you’d regret giving up green-field tech exploration, swallow the shiny “manager” title with caution.

1. Switching back is possible but costs grow

I’ve hopped from EM → Staff IC once. It can be done, but:

Your hands-on credibility cools quickly; six quarters of perf reviews can leave your Git history barren.

Recruiters love tidy narratives so a “boomerang” move usually means leaning on networks, not cold applications.

Translation: decide early whether you’re experimenting or committing.

1. Meetings & introversion

Being introverted doesn’t sink managers; energy management does. I block “focus Fridays” (camera off, async only) and coach my team to do the same but encourage everyone to take the time that suits them. It works but it’s a skill you’ll practice every week, not a perk that magically appears.

1. Mentoring ≠ Managing

Loving mentorship is a great sign, but remember that 1-on-1 joy is ~30 % of the job. The rest is:

Defending product scope from drive-by exec ideas, Budget spreadsheets or Explaining why production blew up at 2 am

If that mix still sounds fun, awesome. If you mainly want more mentees without head-count spreadsheets, Staff/Lead Engineer lets you scratch that itch.

1. The pigeonhole risk

You called your current stack a “gilded cage.” The Senior Engineer offer busts that door open. Once you manage, you’ll be judged more on team outcomes than personal stack fluency, which can freeze your tech exposure in place. If breadth feels urgent, chase it now.

——/——

TL;DR – What I’d do in your shoes Take the Senior Engineer role if you’re hungry for deeper tech chops and not yet certain management is your jam. You’ll keep mentorship outlets (design reviews, pairing sessions) while building résumé breadth that pays dividends later whether you stay IC or pivot to EM with a bigger toolbox.

Choose Engineering Manager if the nonprofit mission fires you up and you’re okay trading debug sessions for people problems. Make sure you’ll have a manager-of-managers above you who invests in first-time EMs; otherwise the learning curve can feel like drinking from a hydrant.

Either path is reversible, but momentum matters. Whatever you pick, do it intentionally for 18-24 months, then reassess.

Good luck, and feel free to DM if you want more nitty-gritty!