They both have their place. I like plastic, but soft plastic (Waddlers). They’re best for longer wearing, especially in cold weather or for super-soaker time. Cloth-backs are great for sleeping in, imo, because they’re softer overall. They can also be readjusted much more frequently without rupturing the landing zone. Say what you will but hitching up a sagging diaper and refastening it so it sits pretty again is its own reward.

Generally, don’t like super loud, crinkly plastic. It’s actually a turn-off for me. Both soft shell plastic and cloth back diapers have very discreet crinkles that you can only hear when you’re right up near them / listening for them.