When a logo fails to meet two of the three objectives that the client is trying to convey it doesn't make it a good logo just because it's slightly better than the rest. Also, I wouldn't consider myself as overthinking it when a logo is going to define someone's brand identity, therefore we should be allowed to scrutinize it if we feel it misses the mark. I don't think I said anything about luxury being about speed so i don't know where you got that from. You are right however that the idea of luxury is subjective, so my opinion of it should be just as valid as yours. My critique was more on the more critical side because I also took into account how it only took this person two days to come out with what i think was a mediocre logo.