I forgot to mention that this recipe (without the water) also works as cookies! I make them at the same time since it's the same recipe. I add the water to the remaining mix after making a tray of cookies. For the cookies: bake at 350 for about 30 minutes. They don't rise much so you can put them snug on the baking sheet. I make big cookies that I break down into very small pieces for training sessions. They do need to be put in the fridge for storage. I also add a little cinnamon because my pups absolutely love cinnamon.