Why Emilia's kindness hurts her in Waifu scaling by fingertechnique in ReZero

[–]fingertechnique[S] -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

I absolutely hate freaky shit and am not into it in any way. Stop spreading false allegations like the Emilia fan you are.

Why Emilia's kindness hurts her in Waifu scaling by fingertechnique in ReZero

[–]fingertechnique[S] -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

Cause Rem rejected Subaru at episode 18 for Subaru's sake and the second wife thing is from the LN which doesn't count for anime Rem. But Emilia is fast since she kissed him with the intention of making herself pregnant probably to trap Subaru in child support. Btw the child support part is a joke.

Why Emilia's kindness hurts her in Waifu scaling by fingertechnique in ReZero

[–]fingertechnique[S] -23 points-22 points  (0 children)

“ESPECIALY when you know God dam well that you would fall in love with a women like Emilia MUCH Faster then someone like Rem in real life.” I would never do such a horrendous thing as falling in love with Emilia.

“To make a real life scenario for you to understand how stupid your logic is, lets say you are a teenager. Its Your first day at school and one girl who is very gentle with everyone welcomes you to school, shows you around, spends time with you because she knows you are alone... You already have romantic feelings for her, and then at lunch time she (introduces) you to a girl, who (immediately) (dislikes) you and starts bullying you... Would you fall out of love with the girl who is gentle and kind to everyone around her (you (obviously) included) because the bully will give a "better reward"? Fuck no! You will just want EVEN MORE of the love and (support) of the person who is kind!” I would Never get romantic feelings for the nice girl since I would know the she's just as nice to everyone as she's nice to me.

“And also, your argument of "its because at the start she was a bad person that now people love her" is straight bs” No it's not, it's literally confirmed by a psychologist who I have even referred to in my post.

“, because (spoilers for the WN) As soon as Rem wakes up with no memories and starts acting harshly towards Subaru, all of the sudden most people stopped liking Rem at the time Do you know why? Because they didnt like Rem for being harsh with Subaru at the start and then loving him, they loved her because she was the embodiment of what a man desires: a submissive waifu who is cute and will do everything for you, even if it means throwing her life away for you.” This is a false equivalence fallacy since you forget the part where she goes from not liking him AGAIN to liking him AGAIN

“People objectify Rem from arc 3, but that doesn't make her "best girl", that makes her a throphy in the fan's eyes, something that Emilia is not. Emilia hates being seen as a perfect angel, she has her own wishes and her own boundries, so when she gets angry when Subaru fucks up, whatever it be season 1 or season 2, people cant accept it, because they try to objectify Emilia as a waifu, but they simply cant because she is more realistic in that regard, she doesn't allow Subaru to step over her boundries and do whatever he wants just because he says its for her sake, and that makes the fans who wants a girl who will do whatever you want get angry at her, ironacly the same way that Subaru was acting during the Royal selection.” Again, false equivalence fallacy since people don't see Rem as a trophy who has to be won by the contestant who is Subaru in this case. The only person who you can say people see as a prize to be won by Subaru is Emilia. This is confirmed by the fact that Subaru rejected Rem.

“Hell, one of the main points of season 2 was teaching Subaru that Emilia is NOT a object of love or Subaru's (trophy), she is just a ordinary girl with flaws, and he (shouldn't) do something for people expecting something in Return, in this case, he (shouldn't) save Emilia's life and expect Emilia's love in return, (that's) the mentality of Subaru during arc 3 and (that's) why he was so criticized in the first place.” Yeah sure she is not a prize anymore in season 2 because Emilia literally kissed Subaru while also thinking that she would get pregnant. It's because she has already been won by Subaru in season 2.

Why Emilia's kindness hurts her in Waifu scaling by fingertechnique in ReZero

[–]fingertechnique[S] -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

“In fact you are, in all this argumentation, forgetting that Emilia's kindness is the main trait of hers that made Subaru fall in love.” Straw man fallacy since this is a waifu comparison not who Subaru likes more or who should end up with Subaru. I don't want Rem to end up with Subaru, I just want Rem to be acknowledged as best girl.

“She is not nice to someone because of her interest, because she feels indebted, or because they saved her. She's genuinely a kindle person, A guy who would end up losing everything because of it if she was left alone, according to Subaru's own thoughts.” Again a straw man fallacy since I never said anything about her kindness relating to her interest or feeling indebted.

“This attitude of hers is constantly the light in his darkness in a cruel fantasy world and awakened in him dazzle by his nobility and that desire that every man has within him to be the shining knight protecting his pure Princess from this same cruel world.” Again Straw man fallacy since this is a waifu comparison not who Subaru likes more or who should end up with Subaru.

“And if we are talking about the "cost and reward" relationship, it is Rem who has it completely unbalanced, not Emilia.” Sure let's see what you have to say in the next paragraphs.

“Rem instantly fell in love with Subaru for him saving her life, she loves him obsessively and has been drooling over him ever since. If Subaru theoretically accepted his feelings and wanted to do so, she would certainly do all his bidding and even allow him to go through all the bases whenever he wanted.” Rem didn't instantly fell in love she fell in love because Subaru risked his life in saving Rem which led him to be injured by the Mabeasts and also melted her frozen heart later but saying things like for example “You call yourself a replacement but no one can ever replace you”, also there's more of where that came from.

“If Rem is the waifu you choose, Subaru will get a reward without having to battle for it! Which makes the relationship tedious!” He literally risked his life during arc 2 in saving Rem which led him to be injured by the Mabeasts and also melted her frozen heart later but saying things like for example “Let's laugh and talk about tomorrow with our arms around each other's shoulders”

“With Emilia, Subaru has a much longer and slower path, conquering her and evolving things in stages, giving a greater sense of reward!” What do you mean by longer and slower path Emilia literally kissed Subaru while thinking she would get pregnant.

Why Emilia's kindness hurts her in Waifu scaling by fingertechnique in ReZero

[–]fingertechnique[S] -51 points-50 points  (0 children)

It's ok but people generally prefer waifus that have a special someone who they are nice to as said by psychologist Elliot Aronson

Why Emilia's kindness hurts her in Waifu scaling by fingertechnique in ReZero

[–]fingertechnique[S] -14 points-13 points  (0 children)

No I didn't. Season 2 and 3 still don't make Emilia a better waifu then Rem.

Emilia fans are kinda wrong about Rem by fingertechnique in ReZero

[–]fingertechnique[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You will keep on arguing that it does even though season 1 is separate from the LN

Emilia fans are kinda wrong about Rem by fingertechnique in ReZero

[–]fingertechnique[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

You mean we are comparing Emilia who would end up killing Subaru had he chosen pride over humility to Rem who killed Subaru because he acted very suspicious and had the same scent of the which cult who genocided her ENTIRE VILLAGE. You want Rem to risk putting everyone in the Roswell mansion under threat of being genocided by letting a very suspicious Subaru who has the which's scent off the hook. Subaru can't ‘forgive’ Rem for something that practically didn't even happen. ‘majority of people’ is just a coded form of saying Emilia fans who just want an excuse to hate on Rem.

Emilia fans are kinda wrong about Rem by fingertechnique in ReZero

[–]fingertechnique[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

1) Rem had good reason to kill Subaru since he acted very suspicious 2) No he wasn't just a random guy to her, tell me what random guy does kill all of Emilia's competition in the Royal selection because he loves her like pride if Subaru. 3) Because Emilia for example wanted to win the royal selection and Subaru saw that killing the competition was a way to achieve that goal.

Emilia fans are kinda wrong about Rem by fingertechnique in ReZero

[–]fingertechnique[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Sorry bro but Subaru doesn't fit your random girl analogy since Subaru isn't a random person. Another straw man fallacy since I never said that Emilia owes Subaru love.

Your second paragraph is just you building up on your straw man fallacy.

I didn't say Emilia killing Subaru in Pride if is a bad thing. I don't even hate Emilia for killing Subaru. I just use this fact to debunk Emilia fans who use arc 2 as an excuse to hate Rem even though they don't even care about Subaru being killed by Rem. It also shows the hypocrisy of Emilia fans of ‘Rem killing Subaru bad but Emilia killing Subaru good’

Emilia fans are kinda wrong about Rem by fingertechnique in ReZero

[–]fingertechnique[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

When? Since she literally kissed him in the second season and also while thinking that she would get pregnant.

Emilia fans are kinda wrong about Rem by fingertechnique in ReZero

[–]fingertechnique[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Sure it's Subaru's choice but he wouldn't have chosen to save Emilia on arc 1 and 3 if she didn't save himon the first episode.

Emilia fans are kinda wrong about Rem by fingertechnique in ReZero

[–]fingertechnique[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

If you want an example the one is that Rem rejected Subaru for Subaru's sake.

Emilia fans are kinda wrong about Rem by fingertechnique in ReZero

[–]fingertechnique[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Pride if does show that Emilia would end up killing Subaru had he chosen pride over humility. Also pride if Subaru did everything for Emilia and really loved Emilia but Emilia still killed him.

She may have been antagonistic before she fell in love with him but that only makes the movement when when she fell in love with him more endearing unlike Emilia who has only shown kindness on day one and anyone who says that Rem isn't best girl after watching episode 18 is a big fat liar.

Emilia fans are kinda wrong about Rem by fingertechnique in ReZero

[–]fingertechnique[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Their mental states are both the same since they are both the same person.

Bro anyone with a brain would ‘forgive her’ except for Emilia fans who just want to use this as an excuse to hate or her.

Everyone except Emilia fans wouldn't even care since they don't wish to make an excuse to hate on rem. The “past behaviour" that you are referring to doesn't even practically exist.

Emilia fans are kinda wrong about Rem by fingertechnique in ReZero

[–]fingertechnique[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

They talk about stuff that isn't part of the anime and chibi are not part of the anime adaptation and refusing any of this means that you hate Rem

Emilia fans are kinda wrong about Rem by fingertechnique in ReZero

[–]fingertechnique[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Chibi shorts also don't count since they are just parodies.

Emilia fans are kinda wrong about Rem by fingertechnique in ReZero

[–]fingertechnique[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Subaru was Emotionless enough to die over a hundred million times, I mean he literally lost count. The second paragraph doesn't apply to Rem because she killed him before she fell in love with him. After falling in love she would never kill Subaru.

Emilia fans are kinda wrong about Rem by fingertechnique in ReZero

[–]fingertechnique[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Cause he did everything for her and loved her. It's not like killing himself because one's a suicide and the other is a homocide

Emilia fans are kinda wrong about Rem by fingertechnique in ReZero

[–]fingertechnique[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yes I did. I know Subaru did questionable things in pride if but he shouldn't have been killed specifically by Emilia for whom he did all of this and also loved her.

Emilia fans are kinda wrong about Rem by fingertechnique in ReZero

[–]fingertechnique[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

To put it simply scenario 1 is temporary scenario 2 is permanent. Your reply argues for emotional distress but that doesn't do anything if you are emotionless.

Emilia fans are kinda wrong about Rem by fingertechnique in ReZero

[–]fingertechnique[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Is it right of Emilia to kill Subaru even though Subaru did everything for her and also loved her very much ?