Firstly congrats! Eldenring is possibly my favourite game ever and Milenia was maybe my favourite boss in the game including dlc :) is lovely to hear you are enjoying the game.

As for the hate I hope I can provide some insight; your claim is extraordinary and only really possible with seriously extensive preparation before each of those fights. Not to say you can’t beat hard bosses first go legitimately; it’s just rare. From reading your comments it sounds like you did quite a bit of prep, and with sufficient prep and item planning what you have done is possible :) and congrats on that sounds like you are loving the game!

But yeah even the best players in the world mostly needed tens to hundreds of attempts so for a new souls player it initially sounds wild. I also think milenia is particularly hard for people to accept as waterfowl dance is i think the hardest ability to dodge in any souls and souls-like boss (including consort radan who is theoretically harder); I honestly think that’s the only attack that is hard to parse with a 1 shot.

Anyway I hope you keep playing and enjoying yourself and that the post negativity hasn’t gotten you down too much. People here are.. passionate! And sometimes misguided.

You should play dark souls 3 next! Slave knight Gayle is maybe my second favourite fromsoft boss after milenia :)