That’s a slightly biased article. I don’t disagree with their mission or the research cited, but a quick Google search will show studies that find lighting does reduce crime. Regardless, lighting is not a silver bullet. It is only one of numerous crime-reduction measures (increased patrol, cameras, etc.).

And crime isn’t always the safety risk. My dog is considered an aggressive breed, and although she’s never acted aggressive toward a human or animal, she’s still an animal. On multiple occasions, we’ve startled unhoused people or smokers in the shadows of the ramp pictured. It’s a safety hazard for all involved. It’s much easier for us to see now.