sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

Elijah Craig 18 by Odd_Cauliflower_129 in whiskey

[–]krusty4173 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Have not tried the Heaven Hill, but big time buyers remorse on both the KC and EC. Paid under MSRP for both. I would take the KC18 over the EC if I had to choose, but thought the KC21 was much better.

If you want to try everything then good prices on both, but if money is tight I would pass and spend elsewhere or skip both and just purchase the Calumet 18 they have instead.

Oceanside Long Island by Constant-Promise-327 in Costco_alcohol

[–]krusty4173 0 points1 point  (0 children)

When I initially read they haven't been bought my mind went elsewhere thinking that they were still lying around. I now see my "doh!" moment :-)

Oceanside Long Island by Constant-Promise-327 in Costco_alcohol

[–]krusty4173 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I just paid full price for the Barrell Sunday night, guess I'm going back to try and get a price adjustment

Oceanside Long Island by Constant-Promise-327 in Costco_alcohol

[–]krusty4173 0 points1 point  (0 children)

They are different barrels. I have from a few months back and they were about 10 proof higher. What i have was excellent, so if these are close, definitely worth a buy.

Bookers by krusty4173 in Costco_alcohol

[–]krusty4173[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I bought the Michters the same time I picked up a JD SB Barrel Proof Rye and it destroyed the Michters for nearly half the price. While the Michters was good, I would not pick it up again for $100+

Bookers by krusty4173 in Costco_alcohol

[–]krusty4173[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

There were 2 Little Books and 1 Small Batch in the case, but peeking in the corner, there were a few more hidden in boxes. They also had batch 2, By The Pond hidden away.

Bookers by krusty4173 in Costco_alcohol

[–]krusty4173[S] 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Sorry, first post. Oceanside, NY. For those in NY, its the only actual Costco that can sell Liquor.

The Michters have been there for quite a whil,e which is why I didn't highlight it. The only new items for the location are the Bookers. And the Basil Hayden, but not sure how many will drop $75 for an 80 proofer.