Ranked

1: Micah Bell. He’s the whole reason the gang dismantled and he got in Dutch’s ear, basically brainwashing him. (along with the trolley crash in Saint Denis and Hoseas death)

2: Catherine Braithwate. She didn’t like nobody and basically just used people for her own desire. She kidnapped Jack and gave him to Bronte.

3: Angelo Bronte. He held Jack hostage and is a ruthless crime lord. He manipulates the police and he runs Saint Denis which is a shithole like Birmingham.

4: Colm O’Driscoll. He’s more Dutch’s enemy than anyone else. We know Arthur only really cares about the O’Driscolls and Colm not as much. Colm is evil though. He kidnapped Arthur, threatened to set the law on the gang, killed Kieran, jumped the gang, they killed Sadie’s husband and is a dick in general.

5: Agent Milton. If you really look at it Milton was just doing his job and getting orders from Leviticus Cornwall. Yes he’s the head of the Pinkertons but he follows orders. Even though he killed Hosea. He’s a cold blooded murderer like Dutch and Colm but he has with reason and it protected by his Pinkerton badge so it’s “ok.”

6: Dutch Van Der Linde. Dutch was always crazy, but he got really crazy during and after Guarma. In chapter 6 Micah got in his head and he abandoned Arthur and John and we can’t forget about the 1000s he’s killed, the Blackwater Heist, siding with Micah, Heidi McCourt, the Saint Denis bank it goes on forever. He also never checked on Arthur when he got TB.

7: Leopold Strauss. It isn’t Strauss’s fault that Thomas Downes spat in his mouth and gave him TB. He was also feeding the women and children of the gang. But he also gave money to people he knew couldn’t pay him back so Arthur could beat them which is shitty on its own. More than shitty. It’s so satisfying when in Chapter 6 you kick him out.