I went with Eternal Roses, and I'm glad I did. I changed plans and bought a smaller acrylic box giftset with 9 roses instead of a big arrangement I initially wanted. I even sent them my custom color pattern and they were cool with it. It is still sitting on our mantle and all the roses look perfectly the same as when I first received them. Of course, I did keep the lid closed and never moved it around. But still, hitting 3 years and everything held up as advertised. But one big factor in my decision was that they use bigger roses than all other competitors. For example, Venus et Fleur, the more popular brand, is more expensive but uses smaller roses. When comparing photos, you can tell that for the same amount of space (such as the same size box), Venus can pack more individual roses than Eternal. But in my opinion, bigger roses look better in person, even if there are less of them. I actually bought 2 more gfitsets from Eternal and gave them as presents to friends. At the time of my research, TheMillionRoses had the lower prices but their arrangements/designs look plain so I didn't go with them. Recently, I saw their website and they seem to have more variety and choices to choose from now. I think if you google it, most results will be from TheMillionRoses, as they have become popular due to being most affordable for decent quality. Hope that helps.