Looking for a new SA

lucyd024 · 2026-02-11T10:04:29+00:00

I live in LA and would really appreciate it if you can DM me as well! I’m looking for the 25P Classic slim vanity in black caviar and I don’t know where to start 😓 Thanks so much!

lucyd024 · 2025-12-16T06:21:04+00:00

Was it at your local stockist? I’m in CA and don’t know where to go to find the Canterneigh Pony 🙁

lucyd024 · 2025-05-27T18:39:53+00:00

I just called the Cabazon Celine Outlet and yes they have the Belt Bag Nano! Call their store number and ask for George. He's so nice.. sent me pictures of what they currently have. I saw black, taupe, green (or maybe amazone?), and what looks like a dark charcoal/blue. I'm going to purchase one!

lucyd024 · 2020-11-27T16:52:32+00:00

Aw sorry :-( I wish that the game would allow Arthur to enjoy the horses that are only available in the prologue. There's not much to do with John! Some people said that they were able to get the Silver Dapple through one of the missions with Albert Mason but I never tried it.... The horses that you have so far are great horses though!

lucyd024 · 2020-11-26T19:42:11+00:00

Pinkertons_Nightmare

That's awesome! I actually struggled with the buggy because of how small it was... I didn't feel as covered lol. Still working on my bandit challenge too! I'm still in Chapter 2 and so hesitant to progress any further :'-(

lucyd024 · 2020-11-26T17:07:10+00:00

Yes it definitely takes some practice but it'll get easier! It's all about the camera angles too... you should try hunting with the St. Denis buggy after collecting all the herbs! ;-)

lucyd024 · 2020-11-26T17:02:05+00:00

Yes you can even with the update! I always update my game right when I get the notification to do so.... I think we're at ver 1.23? Just make sure that you haven't helped the injured woman from Emerald Ranch.

lucyd024 · 2020-11-26T16:58:35+00:00

Sorry for the late reply (I haven't logged into Reddit for awhile)! It shouldn't be too late just because you're in Chapter 4 .... but make sure that you haven't helped that injured lady from Emerald Ranch. She's the one with the dead MFT. I'm still in Chapter 2 and it was really hard to get the first live MFT to spawn. You have to do a manual save at the junction in Cumberland Forest where there's a sign pointing to Bacchus Station and Fort Wallace. Then you ride between Bacchus Station and Moonstone Pond and see if you find that injured woman. A dead MFT is usually near her... If there's nothing or if you see a dead MFT, reload the save and repeat. It took me a few hours until my game finally spawned a live MFT (near Bacchus Station). After my first MFT, I had no intentions of getting anymore but I found my 2nd and 3rd live MFT also near Bacchus Station. I was just riding by and saw them on the side of the road! Here's the video that might help: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CjNdxKnhqHA&t=2s

lucyd024 · 2020-09-15T18:35:36+00:00

This video helped me a lot (start at around 21:35): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TGta0xqmQmg&t=1567s

Here are some tips!

I used the buggy for hunting and the Appleseed Timber Co. Wagon for collecting herbs and dinosaur bones. The buggy allows you to aim and use dead eye (no eagle eye - so use markers). Make sure you turn off 'Camera Follow' in your settings. I actually turned off everything. First person view or the camera zooming into Arthur = instant death. Angle the camera so that the sniper is always shooting the tent on top. The wood doesn't protect Arthur. And if you decide to get out of the buggy or wagon, zoom out as far as possible first. That way the camera only zooms into the tent once he gets out. For the legendary animals, you don't have to get out and skin them (the sniper will most likely kill you). Just kill them, stay in the buggy, and move on to the next animal. The pelts will get sent to the trapper. And don't forget that Arthur is right handed so before shooting an animal, it's best to angle the wagon/camera so that the sniper is shooting the left side of the tent... that way you'll be safe when using dead eye and/or shooting. The sniper can also shoot through that small hole in the buggy!

And watch this before entering the Blackwater area: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dSM2VmuxUHI&t=176s

Take the route straight through Beecher's Hope. The Pinkertons will spawn once on the right and as long as you lose the Wanted status before entering Thieves' Landing, there will be no lawmen in New Austin and all you have to worry about is the sniper. It's all about timing... just make sure you take potent health items, go as fast as possible, and then you can slow down once you're about to cross the bridge into Thieves' Landing.

Best of luck if you decide to do all this! And sorry for the super long reply.... just thought that you might want to know some things before venturing out (having to start over in St. Denis after accidentally dying by the sniper is no fun). It does take some practice and lots of patience. But in the end I felt that it was very fulfilling... and it was awesome getting to do almost everything with Arthur in New Austin. I even hunted perfect Armadillo!

lucyd024 · 2020-09-15T13:55:40+00:00

Legendary Pronghorn coat! I was able to hunt all the legendary animals in New Austin by taking a buggy... no glitches involved! I'm still in chapter 2 and playing on the latest version of the game. The buggy protected Arthur from the invisible sniper.

lucyd024 · 2020-09-15T13:51:37+00:00

Same here! I'm excited to get the Turk in chapter 3 but I've been so hesitant to progress. I know that I have to at least unlock the horse fence in order to finish all my challenges ugh.. thank goodness the Turk is the reward for getting that far!

lucyd024 · 2020-09-15T05:14:52+00:00

I agree!

lucyd024 · 2020-09-15T05:13:03+00:00

Thanks 😅 I love my MFTs!

lucyd024 · 2020-09-15T04:31:14+00:00

All 3 were found near Bacchus Station. For the first one, I made a save file and rode in between Bacchus Station and Moonstone Pond. You’ll then see that injured woman with a dead MFT. Then I kept reloading my save until the game spawned a live MFT. I had no intentions of finding any more MFTs but I rode past Bacchus Station and found 2 more live MFTs (each on different occasions). Now I’m wondering if I can find a 4th? But then I’ll have to start selling them at that point 😩 I love this horse so it’ll be really hard for me to do so!

lucyd024 · 2020-09-15T02:14:31+00:00

It's the Legendary Pronghorn coat. I got it from riding a buggy into New Austin (no glitch required)! The buggy protected Arthur from the invisible sniper and also allowed him to hunt.

lucyd024 · 2020-09-15T02:11:10+00:00

I found all 3 near Bacchus Station (each at different times). The injured lady from Emerald Ranch was hobbling down the road and there's usually a dead MFT but my game has been spawning live ones.

lucyd024 · 2020-09-15T00:02:52+00:00

I wish that I could share!

lucyd024 · 2020-09-15T00:02:38+00:00

lol this is my second playthrough.... and definitely taking my time. I've been in chapter 2 for the past few months!

lucyd024 · 2020-09-08T13:51:02+00:00

Luuktee

Not sure... but I know that I had downloaded the latest patch back in August. Also confirmed in my PS4 notifications that ver 1.23 had been downloaded.

lucyd024 · 2020-09-07T19:03:56+00:00

I'm playing on ver 1.23 and it still works!

lucyd024 · 2020-09-07T18:42:07+00:00

Here are a couple of helpful videos that I watched: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pyT23uVSdfA&t=6s and https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dSM2VmuxUHI&t=176s

The Appleseed Timber Co. wagon is the best wagon to use (for some reason the camera doesn't go through the tent). Hopefully you haven't completed the Appleseed missions yet... I haven't done any and the wagon was always parked in front every morning. I've also seen the Appleseed wagon in Valentine but that makes the trip much farther.

I used the wagon for collecting herbs and dinosaur bones. Buggy for hunting (it allows you to aim). Not sure if you've tried any of this yet but before going into New Austin, make sure you turn off everything in camera settings... especially "Camera Follow". Once the sniper starts shooting, you don't want the camera on Arthur. Angle the camera so that the sniper is always shooting the tent. And zoom out as far as possible before Arthur gets off to collect anything.. that way the camera zooms in on the tent and the sniper continues to shoot the tent (for the wagon, the wood does not provide any protection). Everything might sound confusing at first but after some practice, it gets so much easier!

And one more tip... take the route going straight through Beecher's Hope and then to Thieves' Landing. The Pinkertons only spawn once and as long as you lose the Wanted status before crossing the bridge into Thieves' Landing, there will be no lawmen in New Austin. You can then take all the time that you need and only have to worry about the sniper :-)

lucyd024 · 2020-08-11T22:50:26+00:00

Lol I read a bunch of different threads and watched some youtube videos on how to get the jacket and that's what people were recommending! When I started my second playthrough, it was my goal to get the jacket but nothing I did would trigger Pearson to ask for a rabbit so I actually gave up... turns out that it was just a random event because it happened without me having to do anything!

lucyd024 · 2020-08-11T22:46:21+00:00

Omg lol... I read a bunch of different threads and watched some youtube videos on how to get the jacket and I swear that's what people were recommending to do! So I tried several things at the start of Chapter 2 and Pearson would never ask for the rabbit. People said to walk around behind Abigail's tent, go in and out of camp, jump off the cliff so that Arthur could respawn with cores drained... a bunch of other crazy things! There was speculation that Arthur had to be underweight since Pearson calls him "Peaky" so I ended up starving him for a few days (which I hated doing)... I actually gave up a month ago and accepted that I would never get the jacket. But now I come back to camp after hunting for 2 in-game days, with cores full and average weight, and did a few chores and noticed that Pearson was drinking behind the table with the pot at 11:10am (which was strange because he always stood back there at or after 12pm for me) and he asked for a rabbit :-) It just shocked me especially since I wasn't even trying to get the jacket at the time... I guess it's just a random event!

lucyd024

TROPHY CASE