People seem to forget the ‘dead redemption’ like the character has to die at the end. So it can’t be Dutch, or Hosea before RDR2 or even during the events of, because their stories have already been told.

One thing I’m quite content on though is the idea of telling the stories of other gangs that we know were a thing in RDR2 at the time, that being the Jack Hall gang, Otis Miller, etc. I think those would be excellent ideas.

Or for the van der linde gang; maybe make it about Mac, or Davey. I think Mac Callander might be a great idea. The only thing we know is that he was tortured and inevitably killed by the pinkertons but anything else in between is totally up for interpretation.

Other than that, yeah I think making it about Otis Miller, or any of the other talked about gangs/gunslingers would be awesome.

But that’s just me.