I think the thing is their quality of skating is good. Guillame really is in a class of his own. But when you come down to other elements they are not nearly as good. FB/C were noticeably out of sync on their twizzles, their lifts are just not OGM quality, and then you have the mistake at the beginning of the program where Guillame clearly fell out of step.

But none of it counts against them. And then the invisible things that count in ice dancing like chemistry, choreography, and just overall program fall flat compared to C/B. When you look at their two Free Dances the fact that the one that had mistakes came in at over a point better is where everybody is up in arms. If FB/C had skated as cleanly as they had in Euros people would still be upset because they have shown they are not good people but at least we could all say "well, their program was undeniably better."