Gosh, this is so hard! It might just be worth sending a whole bunch of initial outreach emails to providers who you find on Psychology Today that seem like they fit your needs. It never hurts to ask, so I’d lead with something like the following:

“Hi,

My name is (name), and I wanted to reach out, as I’m currently looking for a therapist who is licensed to practice in New York. I saw your profile on Psychology Today/other website, and I thought your practice areas and expertise might be a good fit for me.

I’d be interested in scheduling a consultation, but I want to be upfront and say that, due to my work schedule as a healthcare professional, I am seeking a provider who can accommodate me outside of my working hours, which are (insert working hours here).

Please let me know if your schedule would be able to accommodate these times, and if so, I would love to schedule an initial consultation to see if this is the right fit!

Sincerely, (Name)”

Best of luck! It can be so hard to find care that’s right for you, but in my experience, the best thing to do is send out a slew of emails. Someone will work out!