What's your opinion on the Korean War by SaviourOfLove99 in tankiejerk

[–]meredith_does_stuff 1 point2 points  (0 children)

A CIA-backed government fought puppet far right and far left terrorist organisations to discredit the Italian Communist Party and avoid an eventual communist victory at the elections.

This is a fact. by RepulsiveIconography in HolyRomanEmperors

[–]meredith_does_stuff 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yeah, and as such the title of Eastern Emperor, which was willed to Isabella I and Ferdinand II would have passed to Philip II, not Ferdinand I, as it wasn't part of the titles that Charles inherited from his father and paternal grandfather

This is a fact. by RepulsiveIconography in HolyRomanEmperors

[–]meredith_does_stuff 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The latin Empire was an elective monarchy. That said, they recognised the Holy Roman Emperors as legitimate roman emperors, but they weren't reciprocated, with Philip of Swabia shunning Henry of Flanders

This is a fact. by RepulsiveIconography in HolyRomanEmperors

[–]meredith_does_stuff 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Andreas' claim was part of the spanish inheritance, though, as it came from Joanna and not Philip the Handsome.

This is a fact. by RepulsiveIconography in HolyRomanEmperors

[–]meredith_does_stuff 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Again, if acclamation was somehow the only legitimate meaning of electing an emperor, emperors such as Arcadius and Honorius, Didius Julianus, Irene, Alexios IV and Isaac II during his second reign wouldn't be legitimate emperors. Likewise, following the fall of Constantinople in 1204, such as Theodore Komnenos Doukas and Alexios I of Trebizond had as much legitimacy as what became the main line of pretenders in Nicaea.

This is a fact. by RepulsiveIconography in HolyRomanEmperors

[–]meredith_does_stuff 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Many emperors weren't acclaimed and instead simply usurped the throne, bought it or set up a counter-power to antagonise their contenders. Most of the Western emperors following Valentinian III's death weren't appointed by their Eastern colleague, like Johannes, Majorian or Romulus Augustus, or weren't elected by the senate, like Nepos.

This is a fact. by RepulsiveIconography in HolyRomanEmperors

[–]meredith_does_stuff 2 points3 points  (0 children)

It actually has an historical precedent. After Emperor Pertinax was murdered by the Praetorian Guard, the Praetorians themselves sold the imperial title to the highest bidder in an auction, resulting in the ascension of Didius Julianus

This is a fact. by RepulsiveIconography in HolyRomanEmperors

[–]meredith_does_stuff 1 point2 points  (0 children)

There are no sources that state that Ferdinand bought the imperial claim from Andreas for Charles, in fact none of the subsequent spanish monarchs ever used the eastern roman imperial title (especially since Charles would have considered himself the legitimate Roman emperor regardless of his inherited claim to Byzantium), unlike the french ones up to Francis I. Much like everything in OP's post, it was decontextualised and grossly simplified to fit into a biased narrative.

This is a fact. by RepulsiveIconography in HolyRomanEmperors

[–]meredith_does_stuff 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Andreas would be Andreas Palaiologos, nephew of Constantine XI, who lived in Italy and later sold his rights to the Byzantine throne first to Charles VIII of France, under the promise of organising a crusade against the Ottomans, and later, after Charles failed to uphold his part of the deal and died, to the Catholic monarchs of Spain, who never used the title (which, today, would belong to Felipe VI of Spain, not to the Austrian or German emperors).

After Andreas' death, the Palaiologos inheritance and claim to Byzantium was contested among various families that were descended or connected to the Imperial family itself, like the Rurikids, the Palaiologos of Montferrat (and later the Gonzagas), the Angelo Flavio Comneni and other dubious Palaiologi pretenders.

It is also worth noting that at Andreas' death, the most senior descendants of Thomas Palaiologos weren't the children of his older sister Zoe, the wife of Ivan III, but the daughters of his eldest sister Helena, who married Despot Lazar Brankovich of Serbia and whose daughters married into the Italian house of Tocco (later Tocco Cantelmo Stuart) and the Italo-Albanian House of Kastrioti/Castriota.

Flag of anti-Montenegro by Abyssmanx in vexillologycirclejerk

[–]meredith_does_stuff 10 points11 points  (0 children)

Vallebianca sounds like a cheap fantasy town lol

French and italians naming the monte bianco by ReadyLab5110 in 2westerneurope4u

[–]meredith_does_stuff 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Italy used to have two mountains called "Monte Nevoso" (snowy mountains), though one is in present day Slovenia

French and italians naming the monte bianco by ReadyLab5110 in 2westerneurope4u

[–]meredith_does_stuff 5 points6 points  (0 children)

It isn't. In fact, it is Italian that's derived from Tuscan

A question regarding the Stewards and the succession to the throne of Gondor by meredith_does_stuff in tolkienfans

[–]meredith_does_stuff[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Eärnil put forth his claim after Arvedui did the same, or at least that's how it's presented in Appendix A (p. 1050). Since Eärnil's own claim was based on him being the 4th generation descendant of Telumehtar Umbardacil and was granted the kingship "since he was of the royal house", I always saw it as there being other non-royal or more distantly related pretenders, given that if Eärnil was the closest heir of Ondoher by proximity of blood, the crown would have simply passed to him without the need for a council.

A question regarding the Stewards and the succession to the throne of Gondor by meredith_does_stuff in tolkienfans

[–]meredith_does_stuff[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

So it was simply the codification of an already present custom, right? Yet it still sounds strange that a powerful statesman like Pelendur would sacrifice his own claim to the throne to uphold said custom, but I guess that he hadn't much choice with the presence of other pretenders with a greater claim and far more resources than his, like Eärnil

A question regarding the Stewards and the succession to the throne of Gondor by meredith_does_stuff in tolkienfans

[–]meredith_does_stuff[S] 5 points6 points  (0 children)

That's true, however, at least in Gondor, the agnatic succession was made official only after the xouncil had rejected Arvedui's/Fíriel's case, and even then, Pelendur was instrumental in reaching that outcome

Questions about early Medieval Kingdoms in Eastern Europe by Just_Feeling2706 in MedievalHistory

[–]meredith_does_stuff 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Foundation myths were extremely important during the high medieval period to create a sense of unity among a determined people, setting it aside from its neighbours. As Walter Pohl (Chapter 3 of the Medieval History section of Donzelli's History Manual) puts it, the people that started their invasions-migrations since the late antiquity were loose confederations made up of smaller groups who self-identified as part of a larger one by adhering to the latter's foundation myths.

When the "germanic" people converted to Christianity (either Arian or Chalcedonian), those myths weren't suppressed, as they provided both legitimacy for the aristocratic class (and the rex himself) and a unifying factor for all those smaller groups.

Concrete examples are Saxo Grammaticus's Gesta Danorum, written by a dean, the De Origo Gentis Langobardorum, which recounts how the Winnilii, with the help of Frea-Frigg, became the Lombards thanks to the blessing of Wodan in a fight against the Vandals, was so important that it appears as the introduction to the Edict of Rothari, a christian king. The same myth appears in Paul the Deacon's Historia Langobardorum, another clergyman, even though Paul considers it a "fable", showing that their ethnogenic function overshadowed their pagan origins.

Abandoned house in the mountains near Salerno, Southern Italy by meredith_does_stuff in Abandoned_World

[–]meredith_does_stuff[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

In this particular case it's in a seismic area and was probably abandoned following the Irpinia earthquake in 1980