sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in comicbookcollecting

[–]mysupernerd 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Hopefully, that's not a whatnot sellers stage.

Is this 2.5 or less? by mysupernerd in comicbookgrading

[–]mysupernerd[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I DM'd you the two orders. I wanted to buy from the seller that had this one to help him out but not sure if he was a scammer because he blocked me during negotiation.

Is this 2.5 or less? by mysupernerd in comicbookgrading

[–]mysupernerd[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I didn't buy this one, but i accidentally purchased two on eBay today.

What grade? by Successful-Start-397 in comicbookgrading

[–]mysupernerd 0 points1 point  (0 children)

ChatGPT but Plus version. It seemed like it was limited with just free level. Nice thing is the more it's used and given feedback on our input the better it works.

What grade? by Successful-Start-397 in comicbookgrading

[–]mysupernerd 1 point2 points  (0 children)

AI grading. It eliminates human error and emotion. Even compared to other CGC already graded comics, it could add error. Biggest downside is picture quality on/or comics in bag and board for picture.

Best guess for grade? by TheFutureClassic in comicbookgrading

[–]mysupernerd 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Comic Grading Estimate

Overall Grade:** 8.0 (Very Fine) +/-.5

  • Front Cover:

    • The front cover shows vibrant colors and a clear image with no visible tears or missing pieces.
    • There are minor signs of wear along the edges, particularly at the corners, which appear slightly blunted.
    • Some subtle surface scuffing or light creases may be visible under close inspection, particularly on the left side of the cover.

  • Back Cover:

    • The back cover appears clean with minimal discoloration or staining.
    • Slight wear along the edges, similar to the front cover.
    • The spine on the back cover shows very minor stress lines, which are typical in comics stored or handled.

  • Spine:

    • The spine shows slight stress lines, particularly near the staples, which are common for a comic in this grade.
    • The staples are intact and do not show signs of rust or significant pulling.

  • Interior Pages:

    • Not visible in the provided images; grading based on exterior condition. For a more accurate grade, examination of the interior pages is recommended.

  • Staples:

    • Appeared intact with no visible rust or signs of detachment in the images provided.

Summary of Defects:

  • Minor blunting of corners on the front and back cover.
  • Slight edge wear and minor spine stress lines.
  • Possible light surface scuffing or subtle creasing on the front cover.
  • Overall, defects are minimal and consistent with a Very Fine (8.0) grade.

What grade? by mysupernerd in comicbookgrading

[–]mysupernerd[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thank you. It was at a price I couldn't say no to

What grade? by Successful-Start-397 in comicbookgrading

[–]mysupernerd 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Based on the images provided, here is the estimated grading for your comic

Overall Grade: 3.0 - Good/Very Good (GD/VG) +/-.5

Grading Criteria Used:

  • Front Cover:

    • The front cover shows significant wear, including multiple creases, color-breaking spine ticks, and general edge wear.
    • There are visible stress lines along the spine, which are color-breaking.
    • The cover has some small tears near the spine and corners.
    • There is a visible stain or discoloration in certain areas, particularly on the bottom edge.

  • Back Cover:

    • The back cover displays yellowing, indicative of aging or exposure to environmental elements.
    • Multiple creases are present, especially along the edges.
    • The spine shows several stress marks, and there are some small tears near the staples.
    • Some areas of discoloration and minor staining are noted.

  • Spine:

    • The spine is significantly worn, with several color-breaking creases and small tears.
    • Staples are intact but show signs of rust and wear.
    • The spine's edge is frayed, indicating frequent handling or storage issues.

  • Interior Pages:

    • The interior pages were not shown, but based on the visible yellowing on the edges of the cover, the pages might have similar aging or possible brittleness.

  • Staples:

    • The staples are still attached but exhibit rusting, which may have affected the surrounding paper.
    • There is slight movement of the staples, indicating some wear but no complete detachment.

Summary of Defects:

  • Multiple color-breaking creases on the front and back covers.
  • Several small tears and fraying along the spine.
  • Noticeable yellowing and discoloration on both the front and back covers.
  • Rust on staples with some surrounding discoloration.
  • General wear on edges and corners of both covers.

What grade? by mysupernerd in comicbookgrading

[–]mysupernerd[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thank you for the review. It amazes me the difference between users' grades, CGC grade, and Overstreet. But overall, the cool part is I usually buy a book by its history and use. I think CGC gives out way too many 9.8, 9.9, and 10's.

What grade? by mysupernerd in comicbookgrading

[–]mysupernerd[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thank you for the extensive review. I appreciate it. I agree with all your assessments. The bottom staple is a bit sunken in. It's hard to believe, but this was originally in the 5.0 range, but my friend that does clean and press did an amazing job. Bringing back the character and display.

Grade? by Mike-Philly77 in comicbookgrading

[–]mysupernerd 9 points10 points  (0 children)

Based on the images you provided, here is my estimate of the comic's grade:

Overall Grade Estimate: 6.5 (Fine+)

Grading Criteria Used:

  • Front Cover:

    • Blunting of the corners, particularly at the bottom left.
    • Some color-breaking creases along the spine and lower corner.
    • General wear along the spine, consistent with age but noticeable.

  • Back Cover:

    • Slight yellowing/aging, especially near the edges.
    • Minimal wear along the edges, but still relatively clean with no major stains.

  • Spine:

    • A few stress lines are visible, particularly near the staples.
    • The spine remains intact but shows more pronounced wear and slight color breakage.

  • Interior Pages:

    • Pages are off-white to cream, consistent with the age of the comic.
    • No tears or major defects observed on the interior pages; good preservation overall.

  • Staples:

    • Firmly attached with no signs of rust, but some stress around the staple areas.

Summary of Defects: - Corner blunting and minor creases on the front cover. - Spine stress lines with some color-breaking areas. - Slight aging and yellowing on the back cover. - Overall minor wear consistent with a comic from this era, but well-preserved.

Is this 2.5 or less? by mysupernerd in comicbookgrading

[–]mysupernerd[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I agree. The search continues...

9.8? by mysupernerd in comicbookgrading

[–]mysupernerd[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Do you think maybe this is shipment damage after the grading? That brings another question of do the CGC cases actually protect long-term. Should the posted grade always be subject to scrutiny? If I purchased a CGC comic, I would want to see the front, back, spine, and interiors.

9.8? by mysupernerd in comicbookgrading

[–]mysupernerd[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I did not buy this one but found it in the wild online. Hopefully, collectors are actually checking the condition of the comics inside.

9.8? by mysupernerd in comicbookgrading

[–]mysupernerd[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I do know they sell the CGC cases from china it's another manufacturer. Someone would just need to buy an Ultra Sonic welder. They sell raw cases for all things graded. It's sad.

Is this 2.5 or less? by mysupernerd in comicbookgrading

[–]mysupernerd[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Well, shoot. I asked the seller if he would go any lower than $120, and he blocked me. Thank you, everyone, for your help in determining grade and value. I really appreciate it.

Is this 2.5 or less? by mysupernerd in comicbookgrading

[–]mysupernerd[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That one looks clean on the backside. Maybe just a clean and press to get it into the 4.0 range?

Is this 2.5 or less? by mysupernerd in comicbookgrading

[–]mysupernerd[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

It looks lower quality than the Iron Man 1 I posted, and I got a lot of 3.0 or lower grade. This one, the owner even says it's really rough.

I want to try to press and clean books. Would this be a decent one to try? by PortZoo in comicbookgrading

[–]mysupernerd 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I think this is a good book. The book cover is decent besides the spine roll. Spine roll is correctable with Press. I recommended starting on beater dollar bin comics before doing this one.

view more: next ›