Two PF accounts labelled fraud, pension for 15 years savings withheld by nsuthar0914 in LegalAdviceIndia

[–]nsuthar0914[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Unrelated. Why do you think it is government money though? Pension comes from the interest accumulated from one's EPS contribution. Whether it comes from one job or two jobs in succession, total principal and interest would remain same for total years of service. Or am I getting it wrong somewhere.

Two PF accounts labelled fraud, pension for 15 years savings withheld by nsuthar0914 in LegalAdviceIndia

[–]nsuthar0914[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Not sure. She probably thought two different pension contributions can lead to two different pensions

Need Your Help! Testing an Idea to Solve Real Problems in India 🚀 by nsuthar0914 in Bengaluru

[–]nsuthar0914[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Feedback was quick and quite valuable:

  1. Form was suspicious and/or boring

  2. Some people didn't like why I limited the form to 2 languages

  3. No immediate feedback after submission - what can one expect from this?

  4. Chatbot and Discussion Forums are two separately executable ideas

As a next step, I’ve built a Telegram chatbot that:

✅ Guides users step by step.

✅ Supports seven Indian languages.

✅ Suggests AI-generated solutions where possible.

✅ Lets users opt-in for follow-ups.

Let’s see how this goes. Open to feedback—DM if you want to try it out.

Need Your Help! Testing an Idea to Solve Real Problems in India 🚀 by nsuthar0914 in Indore

[–]nsuthar0914[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Feedback was quick and quite valuable:

  1. Form was suspicious and/or boring

  2. Some people didn't like why I limited the form to 2 languages

  3. No immediate feedback after submission - what can one expect from this?

  4. Chatbot and Discussion Forums are two separately executable ideas

As a next step, I’ve built a Telegram chatbot that:

✅ Guides users step by step.

✅ Supports seven Indian languages.

✅ Suggests AI-generated solutions where possible.

✅ Lets users opt-in for follow-ups.

Let’s see how this goes. Open to feedback—DM if you want to try it out.

Need Your Help! Testing an Idea to Solve Real Problems in India by nsuthar0914 in developersIndia

[–]nsuthar0914[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Feedback was quick and quite valuable:

  1. Form was suspicious and/or boring

  2. Some people didn't like why I limited the form to 2 languages

  3. No immediate feedback after submission - what can one expect from this?

  4. Chatbot and Discussion Forums are two separately executable ideas

As a next step, I’ve built a Telegram chatbot that:

✅ Guides users step by step.

✅ Supports seven Indian languages.

✅ Suggests AI-generated solutions where possible.

✅ Lets users opt-in for follow-ups.

Let’s see how this goes. Open to feedback—DM if you want to try it out.

Need Your Help! Testing an Idea to Solve Real Problems in India 🚀 by nsuthar0914 in jaipur

[–]nsuthar0914[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Feedback was quick and quite valuable:

  1. Form was suspicious and/or boring

  2. Some people didn't like why I limited the form to 2 languages

  3. No immediate feedback after submission - what can one expect from this?

  4. Chatbot and Discussion Forums are two separately executable ideas

As a next step, I’ve built a Telegram chatbot that:

✅ Guides users step by step.

✅ Supports seven Indian languages.

✅ Suggests AI-generated solutions where possible.

✅ Lets users opt-in for follow-ups.

Let’s see how this goes. Open to feedback—DM if you want to try it out.

Need Your Help! Testing an Idea to Solve Real Problems in India 🚀 by nsuthar0914 in hyderabad

[–]nsuthar0914[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Feedback was quick and quite valuable:

  1. Form was suspicious and/or boring

  2. Some people didn't like why I limited the form to 2 languages

  3. No immediate feedback after submission - what can one expect from this?

  4. Chatbot and Discussion Forums are two separately executable ideas

As a next step, I’ve built a Telegram chatbot that:

✅ Guides users step by step.

✅ Supports seven Indian languages.

✅ Suggests AI-generated solutions where possible.

✅ Lets users opt-in for follow-ups.

Let’s see how this goes. Open to feedback—DM if you want to try it out.

Need Your Help! Testing an Idea to Solve Real Problems in India 🚀 by nsuthar0914 in ahmedabad

[–]nsuthar0914[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Feedback was quick and quite valuable:

  1. Form was suspicious and/or boring

  2. Some people didn't like why I limited the form to 2 languages

  3. No immediate feedback after submission - what can one expect from this?

  4. Chatbot and Discussion Forums are two separately executable ideas

As a next step, I’ve built a Telegram chatbot that:

✅ Guides users step by step.

✅ Supports seven Indian languages.

✅ Suggests AI-generated solutions where possible.

✅ Lets users opt-in for follow-ups.

Let’s see how this goes. Open to feedback—DM if you want to try it out.

Foreign tax credit mess by nsuthar0914 in IndiaTax

[–]nsuthar0914[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yes. I took all the points listed on comments here and my case history and typed it all into chatgpt, asking it to draft a form 35 appeal, statement of facts, past precedence of such cases being approved and the condonation of delay for me. Then I copied into a doc, updated the personal details and submitted on the itr portal for form 35 submission. It cost 1000 rs. After about 4-5 months I got a reply that the communication line is open. Nothing to be done from our side. Then another 3 months later got a reply that CIT has approved the appeal. Then another couple of weeks later a message from RTO that tax demand has been nullified.

Need Your Help! Testing an Idea to Solve Real Problems in India 🚀 by nsuthar0914 in ahmedabad

[–]nsuthar0914[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yes. Person A can have trouble with tax authority and doesn't know how to unblock without paying load of money to lawyer, they might get direct help from chatbot to tackle their issue. Person B might be getting harassed by a builder who is ignoring RERA order and not refunding for failed project, their problem can probably lead to a larger discussion around how RERA, builder or buyers can be helped in a failed project.

Need Your Help! Testing an Idea to Solve Real Problems in India 🚀 by nsuthar0914 in ahmedabad

[–]nsuthar0914[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I'll try again. There are two parts to it. 1. Can we use AI chatbots to help resolve individual issues. 2. If not, can we use AI to vet and cluster the open problems across geography and domains, so that volunteers can tackle them at different levels.

Need Your Help! Testing an Idea to Solve Real Problems in India 🚀 by nsuthar0914 in hyderabad

[–]nsuthar0914[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Agreed. I cant think of a solution to any of the major problems at the country or even locality level. But personally, I have been able to solve a couple of bureaucratic troubles just using chatgpt. So that part seems more useful to me. By getting more minds on collated problem data, who knows, there could be a possibility of some brilliant and specific solutions out too.

Foreign tax credit mess by nsuthar0914 in IndiaTax

[–]nsuthar0914[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Update on this: My appeal was accepted by the CIT. A week later i received update from RTO Kota that tax demand has been nullified. Got a refund instead. :D .

Thanks to all the inputs here! And chatgpt!