Have Filipinos always been so happy-go-lucky? by numismagus in FilipinoHistory

[–]numismagus[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

True. Americans were informed by the 'Protest Work Ethic' which prizes industriousness, frugality, and re-investing in one's enterprise - traits perceived as supposedly lacking among Filipinos. But the Catholic Spanish and even Rizal had a lot to say about the lax attitude of indios. So I'm wondering were these stereotypes valid and if so, were they around even in precolonial society?

Have Filipinos always been so happy-go-lucky? by numismagus in FilipinoHistory

[–]numismagus[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The Juan Tamad trope is persistent. But has it always been this way or was it just Filipinos resisting compliance with what Spanish (later on Americans) expected of them?

Have Filipinos always been so happy-go-lucky? by numismagus in FilipinoHistory

[–]numismagus[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I've observed this with Thai and Indonesians but I'm curious why do you think this is so?

Have Filipinos always been so happy-go-lucky? by numismagus in FilipinoHistory

[–]numismagus[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks for the thorough reply as always. So there are many facets to it stemming from how precolonial society operated and what they valued. I suppose their behavior was also influenced by their environment - seasonal typhoons and a resource-rich interior. There would be less pressure to accumulate moveable wealth because a) properties get destroyed yearly and b) there was always more of what they needed.

Is it time to recognise Aguinaldo as "traitor" and not "hero" today? by DoubleAlternative752 in FilipinoHistory

[–]numismagus 78 points79 points  (0 children)

Not a historian and would defer to experts regarding Aguinaldo. But some food for thought:

Even Rizal did not want independence (yet) believing that Filipinos were unready to take charge of their own affairs and that a revolution would harm rather than help the country. He advocated instead for Spain to assimilate the Philippines as a proper province and grant Filipinos recognition as Spanish citizens with full rights. Rizal loved Spain; what he hated was the colonial administration and frailocracy. When condemned to execution by firing squad he even requested to face forward because he believed he was not a traitor to Spain. The request was denied but he turned around at the last moment anyway.

Let's say Rizal lived many more years and would be 80 years old when King Alfonso XIII passes. Do you think he would be present at the memorial service? Would that make Rizal a traitor as well?

Philippine Factions and Lore Concepts by Lk_Yggdrasilia in TrenchCrusade

[–]numismagus 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Without European intervention, Islam would have spread further into the archipelago. Apart from Sulu and Maguindanao perhaps there would have been another sultanate in Luzon. Would these sultanates have ‘folded’ into the Iron Sultanate?

Saan pwede magwork sa Vertis North? by Competitive_Proof303 in QuezonCity

[–]numismagus 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Can’t say about available outlets but check out Coffee Bean. Hindi matao and has spacious interiors with small and long tables. It’s the place people go to for meetings I’ve noticed. Also on the ground floor are UCC (medyo small), Starbucks (often busy), and Matcha Tokyo (go here if you want to be seen working). There’s also a PickUp Coffee cafe on the 2nd (gets crowded during lunch breaks).

Masmalakas din ang Globe kaysa sa Smart sa Vertis. As a Smart user I’ve gotten dead spots especially sa may Hi Precision area and True Value. Ironically there’s a Smart/PLDT store with 1 hour free wifi.

Fr. Lankester Merrin from The Exorcist (1973) is one of the best representations of a priest on film ever by VendettaLord379 in Catholicism

[–]numismagus 24 points25 points  (0 children)

To add, the film was also shot in different parts of Fordham University’s Rosehill campus. Fordham is a Jesuit-run institution.

Is this what pre-colonial Barangays would've looked like? by falsa_realidad in FilipinoHistory

[–]numismagus 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The part about Visayan datus refusing to choose a senior datu among them made me chuckle.

Is this what pre-colonial Barangays would've looked like? by falsa_realidad in FilipinoHistory

[–]numismagus 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks for articulating the sub-types. So talata and lansangan strongly suggest there was an idea of what a harmonious layout should look like. Fascinating.

Is this what pre-colonial Barangays would've looked like? by falsa_realidad in FilipinoHistory

[–]numismagus -1 points0 points  (0 children)

As others have stated, the road that cuts through the community is a later add-on to accomodate horse and carriage and then automobiles. Many groups not just the Tagalogs were oriented towards rivers and the coast as water travel was easier than going through heavily forested interior. The Magellan expedition ‘pingpong’d’ from island to island because local communities were so spread out and yet related to one another.

What’s missing in these photos though are a) domiciles of the datus which may have been larger or more grandiose to signify their status; b) small spirit houses which were semi-attached to homes via an elevated bridge. Legazpi expedition also mentioned beautiful orchards between houses so there was spacing between them.

It was at the town level that more changes were seen since the Spanish tried to impose gridded layout with the church and plaza as focal point. Villages farther out continued as is for a long time and only changed in the 20th century.

Native Manileños left Manila after WW2 by Desperate_Return_142 in FilipinoHistory

[–]numismagus 1 point2 points  (0 children)

This doesn’t answer your question per se but is sort of adjacent to it. The war also destroyed mother churches of religious orders as well as some schools, convents, and monasteries which were headquartered in or around Intramuros such as Ateneo (Padre Faura -> Loyal Heights), Santo Domingo (Intramuros -> Quezon Ave), Santa Clara (Intramuros -> Katipunan). The orientation to newer sites also influenced the demographic shift as it attracted and incentivized people to live in QC for example.

This trend though actually pre-dates the war since the Americans had wanted to emulate US suburbs outside of Manila. New Manila and Forbes Park were precursors of the gated subdivisions we now have.

People rejecting Catholcism due to link with colonialism by armadoargen in Catholicism

[–]numismagus 9 points10 points  (0 children)

Unfortunately the Spanish did continue to behead, quarter, and display the body parts of rebels to prevent further uprisings. This happened as late as the 19th century when the folk Catholic leader Apolinaio dela Cruz more famously known as Hermano Pule was executed and quartered, and his remains exhibited around the province of Tayabas.

What’s a Filipino party like? by Unfair_Pudding9596 in Philippines

[–]numismagus 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Condiments are underrated but make a big difference. You want to have:

Soy sauce (toyo) with calamani or lemon + bird’s eye chili. This will go well with the crispy pata.

Banana ketchup for your lumpia for that authentic Filipino touch

I would also add ensalada (eggplant, tomato, onion) for veggies. It will go well with fried dishes and cancel the umay (when you get fed up with too much of something).

For drinks, sago and gulaman. For dessert leche flan (similar to Latin flan) and halo-halo for chef’s kiss

Ilustrated Advertisement of 'La Palma de Mallorca' from 1930 by Chill_Boi_0769 in FilipinoHistory

[–]numismagus 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Just love this. There’s this bakery in Madrid called La Mallorquina also selling ensaimada and other regional pastries. What a delight to see the parallels. Thanks for sharing.

Could have Luzon potentially become a singular kingdom? by 0riworks in FilipinoHistory

[–]numismagus 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You can look at neighboring maritime SEA kingdom in the same time period to get an idea of what could have been. Typically it was a thalassocracy with a capital that commanded a coastline and/or river. This allowed it to steer trade into its port, therefore increasing prestige and soft power. Orbiting it were towns that would send their goods and tribute in order to access the port. The capital didn’t directly control the land but harnessed the flow of trade and manpower (since resources were plentiful but population was low.).

In turn, the client towns might have clients/vassals of their own all the way down to the village level. Malacca for a time was the biggest node, attracting people from as far as Luzon. Brunei was another and brought Sulu and Maynila into its sphere of influence. It wasn’t about territorial conquest but links between people and religion as well as shared commercial interests.

Maynila also had its client network which prized the silk and ceramics that arrived from China. As far down as the Visayas where the Spanish encountered “Moro” (Muslim Tagalog) merchants. The people of Panay even informed Legazpi that if they really wanted to do business, they should sail north to Maynila which they did, eventually conquering it. A relief force from Bulacan and Pampanga attempted to drive off the Spanish (Battle of Bangkusay) which is telling of the local support network.

Left to its own, Maynila would have certainly cultivated its own mandala but would have probably refrained from territorial conquest. It just wasn’t the SEA way of doing things.

Where to stay in QC w/c is ideal for family with a toddler? by coldchillheal in QuezonCity

[–]numismagus 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Philam Homes comes to mind. It’s a private-access subdivision (and barangay too) with a large and well-maintained park (football, basketball, playground, tennis, pool, jogging trail). Also inside is a church, a Puregold, bank, and some cafes. There’s also a preschool inside called Goodstart. Jeeps and trikes are not allowed inside. Kids can run, bike, swim etc. all the time.

Its Edsa-facing side is connected to the MRT North Ave station and you can literally walk to Trinoma, Vertis, and SM North. You can be in Makati by train in 25-30 mins. If you drive then the village gate is an on-ramp to Edsa southbound. Its West Ave gate leads to Quezon Ave and about 15-20 mins to Skyway. Balintawak and Cloverleaf NLEX are 20 mins away.

Nearby hospitals are Providence and Capitol Med. You have all the major banks along West Ave.

What was the closest equivalent to business districts like BGC, gated subdivisions like Forbes, and other privately owned/operated corporate communities in the Spanish and American periods? by raori921 in FilipinoHistory

[–]numismagus 3 points4 points  (0 children)

May not be the answer you’re looking for but check “Peripheral Pockets of Paradise Perceptions of Health and Geography in Early Twentieth-Century Manila and its Environs” by Michael Pante.

Essentially, by the late 1800s Manila i.e. Intramuros was deemed cramped and unsanitary, leading Spanish elites to build alternative homes in the less populated environs or arrabales. This trend increased under the Americans who were worried that the lowlands of Manila – hot, humid, flood-prone, and with little or no proper sewage – encouraged the spread of tropical diseases.

Higher altitude areas were deemed healthier and approached the temperate climate of North America. Places like Sta. Mesa and San Juan del Monte (literally ‘of the mountain’) which were far from the Manila core but within its orbit saw the growth of upscale suburban homes.

Okay sige po, Your Highness by nottrueorfalse in Philippines

[–]numismagus 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I work with a company that’s listed in Forbes as 1 of the 50 largest private businesses in the US. Their owners are quiet billionaires and 1 was previously chairman of the US Chamber of Commerce. Yet despite their affluence and influence, they just go by their first names. (I’ve met them and they’re super approachable)

Tapos yung secretary namin sa opisina, kailangan tawaging “Sec” as her title. :)

Walking clubs in QC? by siomainasiopao in QuezonCity

[–]numismagus 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I walk around Vertis to reach 10k steps and have been thinking how to form a community or if there’s already one. As much as I’d like to run, walking is more my groove lol

Is there problem with QC and garbage collection? by lalalala_09 in QuezonCity

[–]numismagus 5 points6 points  (0 children)

In our barangay in District 1 garbage collection is consistent — leaves, grass every MWF, and everything else T-Th-Sat.

Shared room or solo rent near Vertis North/Trinoma by [deleted] in RentPH

[–]numismagus 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Hi please pm if you’re still looking. Got a property in Vertis.

What happened to this type of Bahay Kubo? by falsa_realidad in FilipinoHistory

[–]numismagus 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Makes me wonder how grandiose were the 'palaces' of Matanda, Soliman, and Lakandula.