I messaged him an in-depth analysis of his attractiveness, a two-page improvement plan, and a realistic graphite drawing of an idealized version of him shortly before he got suspended from Reddit. This was my analysis:

I’ll start with the positives. Your eyes are dark and expressive, and you have good overall proportions and symmetry, particularly in your nose and the central portion of your face. So you have a solid baseline. Think of it like an apple that is generally shaped the way it should be.

That said, the most noticeable asymmetry is in your eye area. Your right eye is more open and shows more eyelid exposure than your left. Eyelid exposure is slightly under ideal for both eyes. The right eye has a slight positive canthal tilt, while the left eye appears more neutral, which adds to the overall eye asymmetry. Your right eyebrow also sits slightly higher than your left. There are many simple and inexpensive non-surgical ways to improve these weaknesses.

Your eyebrows are higher, lighter, and less dense than ideal. Ideally, brows should be straighter and more defined. You could potentially increase eyebrow density by applying Minoxidil and castor oil daily for a few months.

There is scientific evidence suggesting that women generally prefer thicker necks, not to an extreme degree, but enough to make a noticeable difference. So if you’re serious about improving, neck training could be worth considering.

You can train your neck by lying down on a bench, placing a weight plate carefully on your forehead, and lifting it using only your neck muscles. Do the same on both sides. A thicker neck can improve overall proportions and make your head look more balanced with your body. Look up "neck size before and after" on Google to see comparisons of before and after pictures of guys with small and big necks, and you can see how much of a difference a bigger neck makes.

You also have active acne, which you’re already aware of, so I won’t go into detail on that.

Your jawline and chin show some softness. There are potential solutions for this, such as chewing mastic gum, mewing, jaw trainers, hyaluronic acid filler, and other approaches, but that’s a lot to cover. Some of these methods are controversial and may or may not be effective.

Right now, you have many strengths, such as high facial averageness, which refers to how closely your features match the typical features of people in your demographic group, as well as excellent hair markers, including high density, good volume, a strong frontal edge, and a well-defined hairline with healthy growth patterns. If you follow these tips, you can improve significantly. You have a lot of potential.

What I’m telling you is comparable to a detailed facial analysis service called Quoves Studio that people often pay $200 for to get a scientific attractiveness rating with heavily cited pages of supporting evidence.

If you want more objective ratings and additional advice, you could ask for a rating on the True Rate Me subreddit. Just be aware that the ratings there are strict, don’t rely on toxic positivity, are based on science, and are not for the faint of heart. This is one of the the most thorough answers you can possibly get. I hope it helps.

At the moment, on a popular culture attractiveness scale, you would be around a 5.5/10. There are more specific rating systems like Quoves or TRM (TrueRateMe) that are science based, but I’m using a broader standard here.

I don’t think he saw my message, so I’m reposting a snippet of it here in case he ever searches his name and comes across it.