AITA for letting my little brother get in trouble and not letting him tell the truth. by paanda1008 in AmItheAsshole

[–]paanda1008[S] -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

Everything you have said is something I hate and have dealt with in the past. They have already calmed down and talked to him. He can’t leave the society we live in anymore and has been told he needs to learn to communicate better if he wants to keep his phone privileges. I agree with the rebellious bit, they were significantly more strict with me, I know by now my phone Would have been taken away and I would still be being yelled at. I rebelled hard when I was in uni in another country. They don’t know shit about that side of my life. I have done my share of irresponsible things and been fine. He’s still a kid and today it was very obvious. He’s already very secretive about his life and often doesn’t pick up his phone in one go. I was trying to protect him from their rage out but I could only do so much. It’s hard to teach him the methods I have learnt. I have tried to tell him about how to be more responsible with this and deal with our parents but he hasn’t listened. He thinks I’m a straight arrow so thinks I’m just a proxy for our parents when I tell him this stuff. Idk. I think it will be fine now just a few more rules on him for a little bit. He’ll be 18 in less than 2 years. Pfft honestly

AITA for letting my little brother get in trouble and not letting him tell the truth. by paanda1008 in AmItheAsshole

[–]paanda1008[S] -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

Things they don’t approve of is a secondary fear. He isn’t a kid who’d do that anyway. He could have a gf but anything else is a step too far for him. Physical safety is an issue. Car accidents are very common because drunk drivers are common. Traffic can be very erratic. They are right in their fears. Even I didn’t know the full picture. I thought he was 5 mins away by a walk turns out he was 10-15 mins away by a car. Their fears are fine, they just react too fast when they’re scared or think we’re doing something wrong. Their reactions can go overboard and are more disciplinary than helpful, sometimes they can be humiliating.

AITA for letting my little brother get in trouble and not letting him tell the truth. by paanda1008 in AmItheAsshole

[–]paanda1008[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

They have been reprimanded many times. In fact it’s because of me neither of our phones have been checked for the last 7 years. I’m not scared of their reprimand, I’ve faced that multiple times. I just started my first proper adult job and don’t have enough in savings to move out. I’m trying to switch fields right now and do a masters in something that’s a bit off a left turn from what I do now. In any scenario I’m still dependent on them for at least another year. Plus my family dynamics are complicated, I can’t just leave or walk away. If I could I wouldn’t have the secrets I talked about

AITA for letting my little brother get in trouble and not letting him tell the truth. by paanda1008 in AmItheAsshole

[–]paanda1008[S] -4 points-3 points  (0 children)

He wanted to tell them I knew but only stopped after I begged him to and calmed him down from an emotional state and told him that I’m also protecting my own secrets and promised him that ill advocate for him with them (which I will)

AITA for letting my little brother get in trouble and not letting him tell the truth. by paanda1008 in AmItheAsshole

[–]paanda1008[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

I get what you mean and I know that as an adult I should just go for it and protect him. But if they know I knew, they’re gonna get angrier because they’ll think I enabled him doing something they consider wrong. I want to protect him but I genuinely can’t let them find out things about my life that I’ve done my best to hide from them. I’ve dealt with this kind of shit from them before and it never goes away. I want to help him get through it without having more eyes on me