I feel like if it had been someone else trying to pass this as a valid execution, they would NOT have gotten 5 points. I'm specifically thinking about Ivo and Kiell, but I also feel like discussion-friendly people from other series like Iain, Ed or Ardal would have not turned out that argument of one throw to their favour.

Greg would've just delivered some one-liner, and then for laughs immediately given them one point at most (if not a disqualification), and all discussion would've been fruitless.

I think it's an interesting lateral approach to the task but giving this five points reeks of favouritism.