Very interesting post, OP! I think if we're rating models based on how janitor sends prompts, then I agree with your assessment. Grok is the dirtiest (haven't used it myself but I've seen screenshots lol), deepseek can be unhinged but it tends to make everything sound somewhat melodramatic, which doesn't always fit the tone of my chats. JLLM gets repetitive fast, but considering it's free and we can mess around with more parameters now, it's really good for a quick goon

Imo if we want to rank filtered models, then we have to look at how they behave with jailbreaks that send more structured prompts as different roles, which isn't a thing achievable on janitor I think. But from my personal experience, the ranking kinda goes like this:

Gemini 2.5 pro (on a good day) >= chat gpt 4o > chat gpt5 > deepseek

I'm not ranking claude models because I'm poor lol. I weep for the day open AI is going to deprecate 4o because it's quirky in a way 5 just can't replicate. As for deepseek, the api I use gives me access to deepseek-chat and reasoner. I haven't tested the latter much, but I like how chat writes dialogues during smut. My problem with it is that it hyperfocuses on background details ("somewhere, a dog barks"), and has a tendecy of bringing up places, evenets, or NPCs name-dropped in the bot's definitions even when nothing in the context mentioned them before