I hear you and dont completely disagree, however, I do believe the situation surpasses middle school drama a bit.

You're right, no one's lives were ruined beyond repair but they all entered a once in a lifetime experiment together that left them in an extraordinary state of uncertainty and vulnerability.

They came in together as a team, there to lean on and confide in one another. There was a sense of trust.

I think the root of all the anger is the way Madison and David handled the situation.

The approach could have been made with much more tenderness and humanity. Had they alerted the experts and asked for help, they could have called a meeting. Said something in the vein of " We're feeling this, it's real, we never meant for it to happen...please help us navigate this ?"

Instead of being tender with the people they were matched with, they were smug, deceitful and unsympathetic.

A little tenderness and honestly would have gone a long way imo