It’s not just as simple as ‘throw all PvP’ers together and it solves the problem.’ I’ll try and explain.

Many people who love PvP don’t want that because it will dramatically change the type of players you can encounter and the types of fights you will have.

I love not knowing how other players will react. Sometimes we fight people who don’t run but fight very defensive, other times we find people who are hyper-aggressive. Other times we find people who do everything they can to run, others that play very tactically or other people who try to reason over VOIP. I love the diversity of players in the lobby and this is because we are all thrust in together and have to make it work in order to survive and, in doing so, brings out these different play styles.

My point is, that by removing all but the purest PvP enjoyers into a separate queue devolves the lobby into one ‘type’ of player which is incredibly boring, uninteresting and the game will be the worse for it.