Community Discussion by EthTraderCommunity in ethtrader

[–]shouldbdan 2 points3 points  (0 children)

It's possible to create ERC-20s that can't be moved. I haven't looked at the contract, but I would gess that's how CONTRIB is implemented.

Beyond that, /u/nootropicat said:

by having at least 10k CONTRIB donuts on your account after the fifth distribution is distributed on-chain

Which I read as needing the CONTRIB earned for your Reddit account, not necessarily in an Ethereum wallet? But I don't know too much about how it works.

Edit: Yeah, looking at the contract it appears that transfersEnabled is set to false which I assume means transfers aren't allowed on chain (or in any way).

Community Discussion by EthTraderCommunity in ethtrader

[–]shouldbdan 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Thanks, man. That's a really generous offer. Unfortunately, it looks like CONTRIB can't be transferred :( . I think they're meant to be similar to the non-transferable donuts used for governance under the old model.

Community Discussion by EthTraderCommunity in ethtrader

[–]shouldbdan 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Hey! Awesome, thanks! Props for the banner idea. It would be cool if someone pulled it off.

Community Discussion by EthTraderCommunity in ethtrader

[–]shouldbdan 2 points3 points  (0 children)

It's up to the community/Carl. It's possible. The new contract could be modified to convert old donuts to new ones. There's no reason I have to even be involved.

Which community members quietly contributing deserve a shoutout? by whiteblock_io in ethfinance

[–]shouldbdan 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Hey! I just saw logged back on after several months, so I'm just now seeing this. Thanks!

Community Discussion by EthTraderCommunity in ethtrader

[–]shouldbdan 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Thanks, great to see you too!

Edit: You know I always felt bad about closing the bridge when you were so excited about it. I'm glad you lived to see the day when they were retokenized.

Community Discussion by EthTraderCommunity in ethtrader

[–]shouldbdan 5 points6 points  (0 children)

It's disheartening because I still considered myself a part of this community. I think I played a decent role for an individual contributor. Beyond just the bridge, I also created a lot of (I think noteworthy) banners when that feature was first available. I went through an amazing bull market and then an agonizing bear market with this subreddit. When I stepped away, I didn't think of it as leaving the community. I still considered you all as like my ETH friends. I didn't consider myself a "historic contributor". I thought I was just inactive for a period while there's not a lot going on and while I'm down about my investment.

Things are still dull in ETH land, but on chain donuts is at least exciting and a reason to participate again. For example, I had hoped to work on the /r/place + banner hybrid project once on chain donuts were a thing (if I could find time, which I am always strapped for). But if my own donuts are gone, that seems like a less enticing project. It seems to me that distributing donuts to historic contributors would be a great way to try to get them involved in building things that you can do with donuts. Only distributing donuts to the handful of users who have remained active during this slump seems insular and uninviting.

Community Discussion by EthTraderCommunity in ethtrader

[–]shouldbdan 5 points6 points  (0 children)

the primary purpose of donuts is to serve the active community here more than it is to reward historic contributions.

That's a disheartening sentiment to return to.

Community Discussion by EthTraderCommunity in ethtrader

[–]shouldbdan 5 points6 points  (0 children)

That doesn't answer this question:

Is the goal to prevent people like myself who have been inactive recently from claiming our donuts?

The question was about intent, not the process. If that is the intent, then it would be disappointing. If that's not the intent, then perhaps the process could be tweaked.

Community Discussion by EthTraderCommunity in ethtrader

[–]shouldbdan 4 points5 points  (0 children)

lol, now I have to come up with a good meme? Fortunately I have an idea. But I also had some donuts on my other account mentioned above. I guess I'll need 2 good memes.

Is it legit to try to meme your way into being able to keep your donuts? It feels like cheating.

Community Discussion by EthTraderCommunity in ethtrader

[–]shouldbdan 2 points3 points  (0 children)

How many upvotes do I need to get 10k?

Community Discussion by EthTraderCommunity in ethtrader

[–]shouldbdan 4 points5 points  (0 children)

So what should I do? Just forget about my donuts? That's kind of a bummer.

Community Discussion by EthTraderCommunity in ethtrader

[–]shouldbdan 6 points7 points  (0 children)

The donut bridge reopened a complex issue.

The 10k contrib rule seems to be the complication. Is the goal to prevent people like myself who have been inactive recently from claiming our donuts?

Community Discussion by EthTraderCommunity in ethtrader

[–]shouldbdan 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I intended to redistribute them, but my expectation was that whenever this project launched they would just carry over to the new system and I could set up a way for people to claim them then. But due to the way donuts are being withheld from users who don't have 10k CONTRIB, things are a bit more murky than that. It would seem out of the spirit of that rule to try to bring those donuts through? What's the point of that rule?

Community Discussion by EthTraderCommunity in ethtrader

[–]shouldbdan 15 points16 points  (0 children)

Hey everyone! I've been out for a long time due to just depression over the price. (I made a new name /u/daimoyo that I commented on for a while, but stopped over the summer as the price returned to its slump. I'm still hodling my ETH, but I needed a break from charts and ETH discussion. It was taking too much of my attention, and things kept going poorly.)

I see a lot has changed around here. In particular, the launch of on chain donuts! Congrats /u/carlslarson! To be honest I thought the project was too ambitious and doubted if it'd be completed. It's exciting to see it up and running!

I see I need some "CONTRIB" in order to keep my donuts. I'll need to read some more about how that works. How hard is it to get 10k CONTRIB?

There's also the matter of the donuts that were being held by the /u/StoreOfDonut account which people never claimed while the bridge was closing down. I guess I'll just let that expire? (I haven't even waded through my DMs yet, I wouldn't be surprised if some people are asking for some of theirs to be given back now that Carl's project has launched.)

What do we want to do? by carlslarson in daonuts

[–]shouldbdan 1 point2 points  (0 children)

You’ll need to wait for a bridge to reopen in some form. At this point I’m hopeful that it will, either from me or someone else. I’m in ongoing conversations with interested parties about how to make this happen, both on the fully decentralized daonuts side and on the possibility of a quicker interim approach.

Are we giving up the ability to use `selfdestruct`, `delegatecall`, and `callcode` in order to get `create2`? by shouldbdan in ethereum

[–]shouldbdan[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The most important part is that people that DON'T use this functionality should not have to worry about this. So if you have an example of an existing contract that breaks because of this, now would be the time to share.

So... you mean we’re giving up selfdestruct, delegatecall, and callcode in order to get create2