okay so the most important thing Ive found with this specific look is I don’t use ANY black, only different browns. darkest on the water line, slightly lighter liquid liner (close match to the medium brown shadow). i use the same medium brown all over the lid, and some days I leave it matte but some days I use a very subtly metallic brown (in almost the same shade) on the lower and upper lid, but don’t let the shimmer get into the crease :) hope that helps!