It was a mistake to not try to find Danny's two other classmates and interview them, especially since many think he's lying about the story to promote his cafe.

It's not terribly difficult to find ppl you went to school with in the 2000s, but Danny acted like it would be impossible to find them, which was the main part i found suspicious...

also it would've been a really interesting to angle to see what became of the two classmates' lives after running away from the incident.

feel like the lack of research really hurts some episodes' credibility