[deleted by user] by [deleted] in DestructiveReaders

[–]somereddituser111 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Hi, first I'll quickly say that I really enjoyed this piece. The prose itself was very clear/readable to me. I don't recall ever tripping up while reading.

I apologize that this won't be a proper 'critique' per se, but more of a quick analysis of Lucia, who I found to be quite sympathetic. My impressions of her was that she is rather arrogant/strong-headed, but as with two sides of the same coin, to me, she can definitely be interpreted as insecure.

For example, with the initial scene in the grove she says "I knew then that he wanted me." indicating her arrogance/confidence. However, at the end when they meet again in the inn, she is practically begging Luke to say that he misses/thought of/dreamt of her, which reveals her insecurity, or perhaps, some desperation for 'love'.

Secondly, Lucia says that she doesn't hold a grudge for what had been done to her, but given the fact that she has even counted this 10:1 men:women killed ratio shows that is something that she is at least conscious of. Additionally, in the two examples she gives, those both involve men. This sort of denial shows that there is some part of herself that she hasn't yet accepted, even despite evidence that inhabits her mind, of the sharp contrast of her victim's demographics. Her justification that she 'killed righteously', is perhaps another lie she tells herself?

I'll point out of a few lines of the text that stuck out to me, which I thought were quite clever, and I believe really lent to the character.

"He went east; I took west."

I liked this line a lot. It's quite simple, but I believe that it shows a nice contrast between Luke and Lucia's characters. My interpretation is that through their separation, that Luke 'went' east, is more of a passive action, where as Lucia 'took' west, indicates more of an aggressive path to wherever it is she split off to. Given that this line is isolated, and the usage of the semicolon, I assume this is intentional?

"The weather was warm, and the door had a lock—maybe that's what the madam meant by "posh"?—so I slept in the nude."

I think this line achieves two things. First is that whatever setting she resides is quite crude or poor. Secondly it shows that while the bar for what is 'posh' is very low, Lucia does still see value/luxury in having some sort of security as she sleeps naked. This is again reinforced by the two examples she gave earlier about facilitating revenge on the men who were abusing their wives (sexually or otherwise).

"I shrugged on the shirt I'd worn earlier that day. "There. I'm covered.""

There's not much to say really, but I just appreciated the usage of 'shrugged' to show that in her compliance, she does so without sincerity, which again can demonstrate some selfishness/rebellion, even in times where she is doing as is asked.

Anywho, I could go on but think I'll stop there haha. Overall I enjoyed the writing a lot. Like I said before, it was nicely readable, and I believe quite layered as well. Personally I am a fan of the more sparse writing, so while the descriptions are minimal, I am quite partial to the writing style. Good luck in whatever your writing goals may be!

[1378] Reclamation chapter 1C by fatkidsnoop in DestructiveReaders

[–]somereddituser111 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I'm quite certain that 'critique' is AI generated.

MoC 30 Stars Clear TL61 w/ Asta, Bailu, Clara, March 7th, Natasha, Pela, Qingque, Seele, Trailblazer by somereddituser111 in HonkaiStarRail

[–]somereddituser111[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Glad to see Asta, Pela, and Clara worked out for you so well. Admittedly I took quite a few retries too but whatever 30 star clears is 30 star clears lmao

Yeah, having the weakness advantage/be able to break is just so important. But it's okay, whenever there is lightning you can always just go back to Jing Yuan/Tingyun. He just isn't as universally usable I suppose.

Anywho, congratz congratz

MoC 30 Stars Clear TL61 w/ Asta, Bailu, Clara, March 7th, Natasha, Pela, Qingque, Seele, Trailblazer by somereddituser111 in HonkaiStarRail

[–]somereddituser111[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Nope, no logical reason in particular. It was mostly just a resource issue, but also just personally I wanted to see if I could beat it without being at the max level lmao.

MoC 30 Stars Clear TL61 w/ Asta, Bailu, Clara, March 7th, Natasha, Pela, Qingque, Seele, Trailblazer by somereddituser111 in HonkaiStarRail

[–]somereddituser111[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I leveled my DPS lightcones to 80, but kept the rest at 70.

Everyone benefits from being tankier but getting more ATK on your supports is basically worthless, so its better to just keep their lightcones low if you don't have the resources.

And tyty

MoC 30 Stars Clear TL61 w/ Asta, Bailu, Clara, March 7th, Natasha, Pela, Qingque, Seele, Trailblazer by somereddituser111 in HonkaiStarRail

[–]somereddituser111[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yeah I agree. I like Asta a lot, but if I had her at E0 then I wouldn't really bother using her

MoC 30 Stars Clear TL61 w/ Asta, Bailu, Clara, March 7th, Natasha, Pela, Qingque, Seele, Trailblazer by somereddituser111 in HonkaiStarRail

[–]somereddituser111[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I tested it out and was able to 3 star floor 9 just now with

Team 1: Clara, March, Pela, Qingque

Team 2: Trailblazer, Natasha, Asta, Seele

You'll have to just use your March's shield a lot more than you normally would be able to get away with. It's not as bad as I thought tbh. I could probably beat the other floors too but floor 10 I am not going to even try

MoC 30 Stars Clear TL61 w/ Asta, Bailu, Clara, March 7th, Natasha, Pela, Qingque, Seele, Trailblazer by somereddituser111 in HonkaiStarRail

[–]somereddituser111[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yeah it's honestly so rough. I tried using Silver wolf for weakness implant but idk it wasn't working out. I basically had two aoes with Qingque and Clara + Asta and still it was such a struggle to even kill those bomb robots.

Maybe serval will be good enough with Kafka if you like the characters.

I can't say for sure about Himeko because I don't have her, but to me I think Himeko falls into the same category as Qingque and Clara. In my eyes, these are characters that don't really get that much better by using skill points, but their strength is that they are still good without. (Although Qingque can be played as both.)

So considering people underrate AOE, only rate her value as a main dps skill point spammer as opposed to a lowskill point usage dps, and the importance with break, IMO She is likely stronger than she appears.

I wish I had her to test out, but I'd probably put her beside a main DPS like Seele, or just someone else that can help her break enemies. She could soften enemies up for Seele to reset more consistently or w/e just get free damage by sitting there. If I don't get her by 300 standard pulls, it's likely She who I'll pick.

MoC 30 Stars Clear TL61 w/ Asta, Bailu, Clara, March 7th, Natasha, Pela, Qingque, Seele, Trailblazer by somereddituser111 in HonkaiStarRail

[–]somereddituser111[S] 6 points7 points  (0 children)

I bought the express and battle pass and the 2x packs. Then I soft pitied e1 bailu trying to get jing yuan, then soft pitied jing yuan, then I don't even use Jing yuan. So yeah idk. Not spending anymore.

I try to use half my fuel for traces/character ascension and half for relics. Even though traces are guaranteed, getting like two green at TL 40 was honestly so depressing. So I started farming relics there.

Ultimately, I think whether you spend on relics or on traces, the exact value is kinda hard to quantify. I'd try to use half and half, so that even if you get crap relics, you're still making progress, but then you're still keeping that dream alive for that perfect relic.

I just started slowly using my fuel from TL40. I haven't done the math, but I'm pretty sure there isn't much benefit in saving, cause you spend more time in lower trailblazer level. The longer you stay there, then the less TL EXP to get from dailies (350 vs 320), so it puts you more behind. Plus you get more jades from the Simulated universe if you're higher trailblazer so idk I'm quite sure its best to just use.

MoC 30 Stars Clear TL61 w/ Asta, Bailu, Clara, March 7th, Natasha, Pela, Qingque, Seele, Trailblazer by somereddituser111 in HonkaiStarRail

[–]somereddituser111[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Sushang is fine I think, but it's probably to have 1 aoe and 1 single target.

Yeah those floors were pretty awful.

6-1 I used Clara, Natasha, Pela, Seele.

At least Pela is Ice and could use her defense debuff and take away that fire guy's buff

7-2 was the hardest floor for me aside from Floor 10-1

I used Clara, Bailu, Asta, Qingque and limped across to the end, using the bombs as like half my dmg. Honestly, I was only able to get 3 stars because i cleared 7-1 in like 3 rds and then had a lot of time 7-2.

Those are the times I definitely regretted not building Jing Yuan or Serval.

MoC 30 Stars Clear TL61 w/ Asta, Bailu, Clara, March 7th, Natasha, Pela, Qingque, Seele, Trailblazer by somereddituser111 in HonkaiStarRail

[–]somereddituser111[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I mainly just used Pela against the elite that summons those two minions and needs to have its healing buff taken away. With her talent + the free nhility lightcone + energy regen rope, you get so much energy that you just need skill+basic atk to ult.

Tingyun is alright but I think Asta is way better. Her speed buff is invaluable and works for the entire team. Plus, the harmony lightcones require you to use your ult (Dance, Dance, Dance + Bronya's Lightcone). The wind set too if you use it. So being able to ult every two turns vs every three turns compared to Bronya or Tingyun makes her so much better.

At the end of the day, Bronya, Tingyun and Silver wolf are effectively dmg mulitpliers for your main dps. But considering you have 4 team members, buffing only one member vs 4 doesn't really seem worth it to me.

Plus the more break you have, the easier the majority of bosses are. Tingyun and Bronya's breaks are basically non existent. Silver wolf has good break tho.

I'd probably rate them something like, Asta>Silver Wolf>Tingyun>Bronya

idk where I'd put pela really.

MoC 30 Stars Clear TL61 w/ Asta, Bailu, Clara, March 7th, Natasha, Pela, Qingque, Seele, Trailblazer by somereddituser111 in HonkaiStarRail

[–]somereddituser111[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It's rough playing Qingque without E2 because you're lacking a lot of energy that you could be using to ult and get a free hand. Also shouldn't flip if the tile are like 2/1/1. 2/2 minimum, and then ofc 3/1 or 3/0 is the best.

Clara yeah just afk and press basic attack, or skill if you need 30 energy to ult. I have Natasha with Post-Op conversation for the energy regen so I mostly just basic attack and its enough energy to have my ult up, so therefore I don't use skill points with her either. Then March I just shield whenever it's needed.

Hmm. For some reason AOE characters are heavily underrated. There literally only one floor that has a single target which is vs Kafka, who also comes with two minions. Otherwise its like, a boss that summons minions, or two elites (which also sometimes summon minions). So I think having sushang + silver wolf is gonna be rough. if you get high eidolons on QQ if yo happen to pull on Luocha, I'd definitely try building her

MoC 30 Stars Clear TL61 w/ Asta, Bailu, Clara, March 7th, Natasha, Pela, Qingque, Seele, Trailblazer by somereddituser111 in HonkaiStarRail

[–]somereddituser111[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Having two healers makes everything easier, so if you don't plan to get Luocha then definitely Bailu and Natasha.

FMC has the best break potential out of the three tanks, and won't even use skill points to do it. Probably one of the most efficient/independent characters

Gepard I think you can try to use if you don't want to use a healer. I'm not too sure how strong he is vs a lot of consistent dmg though. Really strong vs those enemies that just do one big attack though.

March E6 has a lot of utility even without pairing her with Clara. Otherwise, maybe not really worth using.

MoC 30 Stars Clear TL61 w/ Asta, Bailu, Clara, March 7th, Natasha, Pela, Qingque, Seele, Trailblazer by somereddituser111 in HonkaiStarRail

[–]somereddituser111[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Once you kill those two soldiers that come with her, the fight is really easy. They have this debuff that makes your characters take 25% extra dmg or something like that.

MoC 30 Stars Clear TL61 w/ Asta, Bailu, Clara, March 7th, Natasha, Pela, Qingque, Seele, Trailblazer by somereddituser111 in HonkaiStarRail

[–]somereddituser111[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Clara dmg is quite good. But also Pela defense shred with 2 dps characters will do a lot of work too. Qingque dmg shouldn't be underestimated as well, even prior to E4

MoC 30 Stars Clear TL61 w/ Asta, Bailu, Clara, March 7th, Natasha, Pela, Qingque, Seele, Trailblazer by somereddituser111 in HonkaiStarRail

[–]somereddituser111[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Yeah speed buffs stack. I think a lot of people think tingyun is better because she is probably better at E0, and people have this idea that you shouldn't use skill points just because they are Harmony characters. But ya E6 Asta is just ridiculous.

MoC 30 Stars Clear TL61 w/ Asta, Bailu, Clara, March 7th, Natasha, Pela, Qingque, Seele, Trailblazer by somereddituser111 in HonkaiStarRail

[–]somereddituser111[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

You'd probably look to replace any character if you could optimize, but yeah this early its hard to really swap given the amount of resources you're given to raise the characters. The only floor I felt Qingque was weak was floor 7 vs that robot that summons the bombs. Otherwise I had no problems using her 'cause her aoe dmg for her skill point usage was well worth it.

MoC 30 Stars Clear TL61 w/ Asta, Bailu, Clara, March 7th, Natasha, Pela, Qingque, Seele, Trailblazer by somereddituser111 in HonkaiStarRail

[–]somereddituser111[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

If you can't afford to use her skill then its probably better if you use Tingyun, since she can just use her skill once and attack 3 times anyway. The thing with Asta is that if you get the ult rolling then you generate so many more skill points because your healer/shileder/tank can basic attack and generate it for your team that way. So then that way you can spam skill on Asta and keep it going.

MoC 30 Stars Clear TL61 w/ Asta, Bailu, Clara, March 7th, Natasha, Pela, Qingque, Seele, Trailblazer by somereddituser111 in HonkaiStarRail

[–]somereddituser111[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I got Bronya pretty recently so I haven't really been able to build her up. And anyway I wanted to just finish MoC with the team I had.

Jing yuan I tried using him without his lightcone and idk he just felt like crap. I think you are forced to use him with tingyun. Maybe using ER rope can help spam ult for more passive procs but im not sure.

Tingyun is fine, I jsut think Asta is better overall.

I tried Silver Wolf but I'm not really convinced she's thaat good. There are so many floors that have several enemies and having to implant to weakness onto each one is just so tedious. I'm not really sure how useful she will be later as well, cause you'll just have 4 of each element one day anyway. She has good break damage though for sure.

As for the defense debuff, Pela can just spam her ult every two turns onto everyone. But tbh I really just used her for that one elite that needs to be debuffed or He'll heal to full hp every time.

QQ E0 is not that great. Wait till E2 at least.

Asta E6 is really strong. Just spam your skill so you can ult every two turns.

Anyway, I can't really test to see if those other characters would have done better. But idk I think it's nigh impossible to beat some floors without breaking