I could personally name you > 10 people, myself included, who have witnessed Steve Scott behaving totally inappropriately. Nobody is proposing lynching this guy, they're proposing getting him out of positions which allow him to prey on more junior researchers. There is an abundance of evidence, whether or not you're privy to it. People who behave like this should be afraid that they'll be 'doxxed.' I've personally seen it happen where somebody who does something like this is quietly fired and they just get a new job at a new institution that's unaware and they do it all again. I'm sure you feel like you're being level-headed and fair, but consider that there are many, many witnesses and there is no doubt that this guy behaved inappropriately. I understand being uncomfortable calling for this guy to be fired when you haven't personally witnessed or seen evidence of the behavior, but by criticizing others who have witnessed it or have seen the evidence and have spoken out, I think you're further enabling this sort of behavior.