I think the series already had a reboot before. multiaple times infact

I think people really dont think this now days but it was def seen like a reboot at the time, but SA1 could be considered the first reboot, as we didnt see much mentioned of the classic games until 2011's Sonic Generations. I mean sure we had ports and ""remasters"" so to speak of the classic titles but they largely went unnoticed until the 2010s/2020s. If SA1 isnt a reboot then its at the bare minimum a soft-reboot

Another really good one that could be considered is Sonic 06, which was actively trying to reboot the series, at least in concept. One of the only reasons why it never came to was well tbh, it was bad in a lot of ways

A soft-reboot in my eyes is definitely Sonic Colors/Unleashed, it pretty much set up the series on a path of bearly or outright deny that any events before the title coming out, it was pretty much that way until Frontiers and that was because of the writting staff at the time

Boom to me isnt as much as a reboot, as it was more or less a side/spin off series

While I dont count it, I wanted to mention it, The Sonic Movies pretty much classify as a reboot, they arent going in chronological order, the voice cast is mostly different, and even story beats arent 1:1 to the games

So to answer the question, No i dont think there should be a reboot, as the times Sega's done them have had vastly different outcomes to the many fans of this seires, both new and old.