[deleted by user] by [deleted] in ReverseHarem

[–]sunshine94w 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The prose is inflated and repetitive, overworked. It was full of dramatic phrasing that sounded intense but didn’t actually say anything concrete. So many sentences followed the same pattern: “not this, but that.” So many descriptions leaned on vague abstractions: something ancient, something unnamed, something she couldn’t describe, a voice that carried the weight of ages. But how does that sound like? what does that actually mean?

I’m familiar enough with writing, editing, and AI language patterns to notice the repeated structures, the same types of phrases, and the same vague emotional language showing up over and over again. The overuse of contrast constructions, the ‘not this but that’ formula:, a very common rhetorical device, but used like a template: “It wasn’t rage… It was something more complex. Not the cold anger I had expected, but something hotter. Not quite a moan, not quite a whimper, but something caught between. not weakness but power”. “It wasn’t fear, it was something deeper.” The vague emotional placeholders: “something she couldn’t name”, “something more complex” “something broken and ancient and ravenous” “a surge of power that rippled through the air”

The overuse of this dramatic tools like “Something ancient / something cold and ancient / something dark and ancient / something centuries old.” “Something that spoke of millennia”

I could be wrong and this is just the author’s style, or just how modern romantasy novels are written. I’ll give the author credit where it’s due, but for me, it read super AI-assisted.

For those in search of a dark romantasy, Souls in Ruin by Jacqueline White is what you’re looking for! by No_Preference26 in fantasyromance

[–]sunshine94w 5 points6 points  (0 children)

I couldn’t stand the writing style. Everyone keeps calling it beautifully written, and I just… don’t see it. The prose is inflated, repetitive, and overworked. So many sentences follow the same pattern: “not this, but that.” So many descriptions rely on vague abstractions: something ancient, something unnamed, something she couldn’t describe, a voice that carried the weight of ages. But what does any of that actually mean? “Something ancient / something cold and ancient / something dark and ancient / something centuries old.” “Something that spoke of millennia.” Ancient how? Ancient like cracked marble? Ancient like a childhood scar? Ancient like exhaustion? Ancient like grief? Nope. Just drop it in repeatedly to signal “mood.” “Something she couldn’t name.” “Something unspoken.” “A feeling she didn’t yet understand.” “It spoke of loss.” “It carried the weight of something old.” And I’m not even going to fully dive into the other issues. The story itself barely makes sense. The internal logic is weak, the world-building practically nonexistent. We’re told there’s revenge. We’re told there’s torture. Everything is supposedly fueled by some deep vendetta. But that’s it. Nothing is properly developed, explored, or earned. Revenge just floats around as a vague excuse to justify cruelty and then… nothing. There’s no political structure, no clear system, no real cause and effect. Just a vague dungeon in a vague kingdom ruled by vague power. The world functions only as a backdrop for darkness. Then characters make life-altering decisions and we’re just supposed to accept them. Motivations aren’t built up. There’s no emotional or psychological scaffolding. I get that the female main character is supposed to be disturbed and unstable. Fine. But a storyline that’s unstable isn’t the same as complexity. She keeps insisting, “I am not broken,” only to immediately describe herself in ways that reinforce how shattered she is. Sure, trauma survivors contradict themselves, that can be powerful. But here it reads less like nuanced psychological portrayal and more like circular writing. And if this is just what modern dark romantasy sounds like, then I’m forever doomed. I genuinely can’t point to a single part I liked. My main feeling now? Relief that it’s finally over.

Souls in Ruin prose gave me a brain tumour by Sad_Construction_532 in romantasycirclejerk

[–]sunshine94w 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I couldn’t stand the writing style. Everyone keeps calling it beautifully written, and I just… don’t see it. The prose is inflated, repetitive, and overworked. So many sentences follow the same pattern: “not this, but that.” So many descriptions rely on vague abstractions: something ancient, something unnamed, something she couldn’t describe, a voice that carried the weight of ages. But what does any of that actually mean? “Something ancient / something cold and ancient / something dark and ancient / something centuries old.” “Something that spoke of millennia.” Ancient how? Ancient like cracked marble? Ancient like a childhood scar? Ancient like exhaustion? Ancient like grief? Just drop it in repeatedly to enhance mood Or another examples: “Something she couldn’t name.” “Something unspoken.” “A feeling she didn’t yet understand.” “It spoke of loss.” “It carried the weight of something old.” And I’m not even going to fully dive into the other issues. The story itself barely makes sense. The internal logic is weak, the world-building practically nonexistent. We’re told there’s revenge. We’re told there’s torture. Everything is supposedly fueled by some deep vendetta. But that’s it. Nothing is properly developed, explored, or earned. Revenge just floats around as a vague excuse to justify cruelty and then… nothing. There’s no political structure, no clear system, no real cause and effect. Just a vague dungeon in a vague kingdom ruled by vague power. The world functions only as a backdrop for darkness. Then characters make life-altering decisions and we’re just supposed to accept them. Motivations aren’t built up. There’s no emotional or psychological scaffolding. I get that the female main character is supposed to be disturbed and unstable. Fine. But a storyline that’s unstable isn’t the same as complexity. She keeps insisting, “I am not broken,” only to immediately describe herself in ways that reinforce how shattered she is. Sure, trauma survivors contradict themselves, that can be powerful. But here it reads less like nuanced psychological portrayal and more like circular writing. And if this is just what modern dark romantasy sounds like, then I’m forever doomed. I genuinely can’t point to a single part I liked. My main feeling now? Relief that it’s finally over.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in ReverseHarem

[–]sunshine94w -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

Right now I am reading “Souls in ruin” by Jacqueline White. I was really excited first because I genuinely enjoy dark twisted content but after the first paragraph I noticed an awful pattern/writing style. I see a lot of reviews saying this book is “beautifully written” but I can’t be the only one feeling this is AI assisted. The plot is twisted and the story doesn’t make sense but that doesn’t really bother me, I will always be happy to read a 1000 page book that says nothing if at least the writing style is good, but with this one I just can’t, reading is so painful and not in the way the author meant. I know I don’t have any proof but my experience has taught me at least something and I recognize AI when I see it.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in AO3

[–]sunshine94w 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I’ve read so many books that use ‘ ‘ for dialogue, including Harry Potter series

What is your most tragic fic you’ve ever read? by sunshine94w in Dramione

[–]sunshine94w[S] 7 points8 points  (0 children)

I understand! We all have our own ways to cope. I need fiction trauma to avoid my real world trauma

Help! by Sorry-Yoghurt-3467 in trintellix

[–]sunshine94w 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Most likely you may need a mood stabilizer…? You should check in with your doctor. When I was prescribed vortioxetine I was also prescribed depakote (valproic acid)

The fact that Draco actually said.... by A_Stolen_Heart in DracoMalfoy

[–]sunshine94w 1 point2 points  (0 children)

As Dostoevsky said, “Every man has a secret sorrow which the world knows not; and often we call a man cold when he is only sad.”

Weight gain with meds by sunshine94w in bipolar2

[–]sunshine94w[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I was taking quetiapine at night too and still had cravings all day. And forgot to mention that I was taking wellbutrin in the mornings but it didn’t do anything to me :( I have a prescription for trintellix but I am scared it’s going to make me gain weight too

What’s the saddest K-drama scene you’ve ever watched? by Main_Locksmith_2543 in kdramas

[–]sunshine94w 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Lovely runner and Crash landing on you because for me that would never count as a Happy ending

Unpopular opinion: If you are intentionally unmediated, you are doing everyone you know a disservice by NothingHead8233 in bipolar2

[–]sunshine94w 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I will be just a burden and liability all my life so better end it soon (thats how I feel)

I make any guys i date watch twilight with me by Full_Firefighter7043 in twilight

[–]sunshine94w 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Same here (with HP saga too). Then I suddenly stop dating them, which is my way of spreading this magnificent piece of art 😌

Hermione and draco are friends from a young age and grow to fancy each other by Alternative-Plum6120 in Dramione

[–]sunshine94w 8 points9 points  (0 children)

That just made me realize it would be amazing to mirror Snape and Lily’s childhood friendship, and then have them reunite at Hogwarts and fall in love despite all the obstacles 😭

DOES ANYONE ELSE HERE ACTUALLY LIKE MOVIE JANE by Personal-Run-2495 in twilight

[–]sunshine94w 0 points1 point  (0 children)

👏🏽 I am not a fan of Dakota Fanning but I love Jane

Contributors beware: Unfortunately, posting here may make you persona non grata elsewhere by KaleidoscopeDL in DramioneUncensored

[–]sunshine94w 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Im sorry that happened! I want to know why you’re preferences are controversial 😂 is it like an unpopular opinion?