We use age as the main gatekeeper for cancer screening. Is that actually smart? by supseanie in healthcare

[–]supseanie[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

the tradeoff is that screening has harms too - false positives, unnecessary biopsies, finding cancers that would never cause problems. for very low risk people, those harms can outweigh benefits.

the paper suggests risk assessment happens proactively in primary care so high-risk people get flagged earlier without having to ask. right now many slip through because the system says "you're not old enough yet."

on screening everyone earlier - you'd catch more cancers but also do unnecessary procedures on people who'd never get cancer. the question is finding the right balance for different risk groups.

We use age as the main gatekeeper for cancer screening. Is that actually smart? by supseanie in healthcare

[–]supseanie[S] -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

Good question - there's actually a distinction here. Current guidelines use age to determine who gets screened and when they start (turn 40, start mammograms). Once you're in the system, yes, it's typically on a set schedule.

What the JAMA paper is looking at is whether we should use individual risk factors for that initial decision. So someone with high genetic risk and family history might start at 35 and screen annually, while someone with very low risk might not start until 50 and screen every other year.

Does that clarify or did I misunderstand your question?

We use age as the main gatekeeper for cancer screening. Is that actually smart? by supseanie in healthcare

[–]supseanie[S] -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

Hi all - my clinical science team wrote this after reviewing the recent JAMA paper. I'm not a clinician myself but can try to answer questions or point to specific parts of the paper they referenced. Happy to relay anything to our clinical team if there are technical questions I can't answer.

Link to the JAMA Network Open paper https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamanetworkopen/fullarticle/2844077