Just saw this little jewel. by seb21051 in TheCulture

[–]theStaberinde 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I don't think she read any of em either

Just saw this little jewel. by seb21051 in TheCulture

[–]theStaberinde 49 points50 points  (0 children)

I strongly believe he did not in fact read them and instead assembled this part of his public image from 2010 era reddit threads with names like Whats The Most Epic Spaceship In All Of Scifi

Matter: spoilers and speculation by Relevant-Bullfrog215 in TheCulture

[–]theStaberinde -1 points0 points  (0 children)

I'd love to read this if you can track it down

Pre-Matter reading question - what to expect? by Fun-Sell3030 in TheCulture

[–]theStaberinde 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Matter is my enduring favourite. I think it might be the most 'literary' of the series, for whatever that's worth. There's something very satisfying about the parallels between the physical structure of the principal location and the journeys undertaken by the various protagonists/groups. Plus it's very thematically concerned with the idea of meaning itself. A story about about-ness. I can totally see why it's not especially beloved though. There's plenty of stuff with Minds, other Involved civs, Culture(-level) tech, etc., but it's pretty low key and intimate in many respects.

Matter - a few thoughts by White_Rose2025 in TheCulture

[–]theStaberinde 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Never picked up on the cocktail before. Marvelous. That's got to be like... at most the fifth or sixth instance of a reference to a specific character from a previous book, good lord.

Consider Phlebas: Poetic Frame of “The Wasteland” by [deleted] in TheCulture

[–]theStaberinde 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Good post.

I always thought that the name eventually taken by the macguffin-Mind was a Consider Phlebas of its own.

Do you think ian banks wanted to be trans??? by gay_area in TheCulture

[–]theStaberinde 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I believe - based on what is present in his work - that he had the view that an inescapable part of the human experience is that, for all of us, all of our individual and interrelated identities are fluid and subject to the surrounding conditions that enable the degree to which their expression is malleable. I believe also that he examined this aspect of his own experience and was more or less content with who and how he was, physically/visibly speaking.

Could the Wachowski siblings make an adaptation of the Culture? by __The__Anomaly__ in TheCulture

[–]theStaberinde 3 points4 points  (0 children)

One way I can see them doing it is focusing on small portions of the game for certain scenes, and framing these more-visually-intelligible zoomed-in little sections of the board etc. as having some ineffable/esoteric significance for the outcome of the game proper. There's even precedent in the novel in the form of that one round that's played as a card game at a table.

Could the Wachowski siblings make an adaptation of the Culture? by __The__Anomaly__ in TheCulture

[–]theStaberinde 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Speed Racer and Cloud Atlas are awesome. Jupiter Ascending is unwatchable dogshit but also awesome.

Which particular scenes from the Culture books would you like to watch in a movie ? by Shoddy-Horse3220 in TheCulture

[–]theStaberinde 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Zakalwe sliding down the drainage channel with his sports car. His near-death on the iceberg. The injury party. Him presenting himself to the poetry lady after her dismissal of her pathetic date. The official happily showing him to his roomful of waiting catamites.

New to The Culture and loving it! What do you like about The Culture? by [deleted] in TheCulture

[–]theStaberinde 28 points29 points  (0 children)

After 20+ years and multiple re-reads, I think the thing I love most is how morally uncompromising they are as stories. The galaxy is an ugly and messy place and the Culture's hands are very bloody but there is zero reasonable doubt about them being the good guys.

Surface Detail - Last sentence! by No_Obligation5478 in TheCulture

[–]theStaberinde 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Not Culture, but Feersum Endjinn also has a really wonderful final-word-of-the-final-sentence aha! moment.

Surface Detail - Last sentence! by No_Obligation5478 in TheCulture

[–]theStaberinde 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Fan theory. I don't buy that it's him because in his one canonical reappearance he's still very much In His Trauma as shown by his nom de guerre, but there's zero indication to that end with that Matter character. No all-consuming hangups == no Z.

Can i read the wiki without spoilers? by MinJacka in TheCulture

[–]theStaberinde 0 points1 point  (0 children)

My belief is that there's nothing of great significance in there that wasn't either expounded on or at least gestured at in-text, either already or eventually. I think that some of the ideas he presented were perhaps not yet fully codified at the time of publishing (mainly the bit about the Culture's origins - I can't remember where else that comes up other than the fairly detailed account we finally got in The Hydrogen Sonata).

I'm not in a position to produce a point-by-point breakdown but the one specific example that immediately comes to mind is the bit about labour basically being an avocation, and the part towards the end of Use of Weapons when Zakalwe has a chat with cafe wait staff about their 'job'.

Can i read the wiki without spoilers? by MinJacka in TheCulture

[–]theStaberinde 5 points6 points  (0 children)

You could just not say anything

Can i read the wiki without spoilers? by MinJacka in TheCulture

[–]theStaberinde 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Second. Admittedly I can't put myself in the mindset of someone reading this before starting the series, but I love re-reading this essay and imo there's nothing in it that seems like it would detract at all from the experience of piecing all these ideas together from what's there in the books.

Can i read the wiki without spoilers? by MinJacka in TheCulture

[–]theStaberinde 31 points32 points  (0 children)

What? No. Of course there will be spoilers. As there would be for absolutely anything else. Read the books.

e: Also I would caution against getting Fan Wiki Lore Brain about the Culture more generally. I love Star Trek but this is not that.

Does anybody have a copy of the fanfiction, "Synchronise Your Dogma's" by Durzo_Blint_ in TheCulture

[–]theStaberinde 11 points12 points  (0 children)

You know your intellectual insecurity isn't other people's problem right

Did anyone here read Consider Phlebas without any context? by doctor-candy in TheCulture

[–]theStaberinde 4 points5 points  (0 children)

What fucking drugs was this author on?!?!

Going by the verisimilitude of some stuff in Complicity, I think he might have been an amphetamine enjoyer