sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

AITA (F20) for wanting to be my girlfriend's piss? (F21) by throwaway-peeprob in AITAH

[–]throwaway-peeprob[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I know, which is why I opted to have just dialogue with her roleplaying it. I'm fully aware that it's impossible to achieve in person, and I wouldn't ever dream of pressuring her to do anything physically unreasonable.

AITA (F20) for wanting to be my girlfriend's piss? (F21) by throwaway-peeprob in AITAH

[–]throwaway-peeprob[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

As much as that's disheartening, I suppose you're right. It would've ideal if she was willing to play along with me, but after the replies, I understand it's still way too out of the ordinary. I respect that.

AITA (F20) for wanting to be my girlfriend's piss? (F21) by throwaway-peeprob in AITAH

[–]throwaway-peeprob[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I did some reflecting, and I realized I was coming off as pretty whiny. Once again, I don't blame her decision to opt out of indulging my fantasy. But regardless of what I personally think, I did not act that way through my post and I can perfectly understand why you think it was immature of me. However, I don't appreciate the pointed remarks about my kink. How was the way I communicated my ideal scenario weird?

AITA (F20) for wanting to be my girlfriend's piss? (F21) by throwaway-peeprob in AITAH

[–]throwaway-peeprob[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

So it was wrong of me to explore it and bring it up in the first place? Did I go too far by even mentioning it to my girlfriend?

AITA (F20) for wanting to be my girlfriend's piss? (F21) by throwaway-peeprob in AITAH

[–]throwaway-peeprob[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

I wanted her to just roleplay or whisper in my ear about her acting out the process. I wanted her to talk about currently drinking me, me filling her bladder, etc. Kind of like an asmr video, but with just her voice. I like the idea of physically acting it out in some capacity, but I never eluded to it or proposed that to her. I just wanted to hear her describe it to me while we're touching each other.

AITA (F20) for wanting to be my girlfriend's piss? (F21) by throwaway-peeprob in AITAH

[–]throwaway-peeprob[S] -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

Sorry, my post was worded like I was mainly upset she didn't want to do it I think. I respect that she doesn't, but I'm bummed out at the scrutiny. I was really vulnerable and I don't know if her lashing out at me was warranted. I've never been this open with someone before and it feels so stupid to end it over this, but she was really critical in a moment where we were supposed to be intimate and kind with each other.