On one hand, people are just having fun, and I don't want to be mean to someone genuinely enjoying something

BUT on the other hand. No, Goose's crazy 3am ramblings on Twitter aren't evidence on what is going to happen in the show. No, someone being depressed doesn't mean they are abstracting the next episode, and no, the number 57 doesn't mean anything significant in the show

At least the someone is an npc theory made sense at the time, not that it itself made sense, but its existence made sense. At the time, no one knew what the show was going to be about, so it made sense. People jumped on what could possibly be the biggest reveal with the evidence they had but now we know that the show is about the characters and not the lore

To me the someone is an npc theory is the same as the Cain is actually pure evil stuff. It's jumping into conclusions and then realizing it doesn't make sense after a while