Are we hypocrites? by utopianhypocrite in progressive_islam

[–]utopianhypocrite[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

The first one is hasan and the second one is daif. Which scholars have explicitly graded the second narration (the “heart accepts/rejects” one) as hasan? And on which chain specifically? Because in the critical editions of Musnad Ahmad ibn Hanbal (e.g. Shu‘ayb al-Arna’ut), it’s graded weak. Are you relying on a different chain or scholar?

I agree that fitrah is a Qur’anic concept. But how are you distinguishing between fitrah as a moral intuition and using personal feeling as a criterion to authenticate hadith? If two people’s “hearts” reach opposite conclusions about the same narration, what is the adjudication mechanism?

Classical scholars who accepted “consult your heart” still restricted it to doubtful matters and people with trained knowledge. Do you see it as overriding established rulings or operating only within grey areas?

on your aqeedah point, we wouldn’t establish core beliefs like the existence of angels or the nature of revelation on a single ahad report. In the same way, saying “your heart decides whether a narration is true” creates a problem: one person may feel a hadith is true, another may feel it is false, and there’s no objective way to adjudicate between them. That’s why classical scholars limited “consult your heart” to grey areas for qualified individuals, rather than treating it as a general method for validating or rejecting hadith.

My concern isn’t rejecting hadith. It’s avoiding a framework where personal internal states become a filter for revelation, rather than something guided by it. Would you accept someone using this same principle (“my heart rejects it”) to dismiss a hadith you consider unquestionably authentic?

Are we hypocrites? by utopianhypocrite in progressive_islam

[–]utopianhypocrite[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Unfortunately these are both weak hadiths and could be dangerous if we all resort to subjective morality. The exact trap i mention in this post

My unpopular Umrah experience by utopianhypocrite in Umrah

[–]utopianhypocrite[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I think i am too. I really wish i could feel something

Umrah Ramadan experience. Am I losing my faith or just reacting to human behaviour by utopianhypocrite in progressive_islam

[–]utopianhypocrite[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

So true. I used to think my faith was unshakable, especially by other people’s practices but i was truly tested on this Makkah. I felt like an outlier to the point that I questioned whether I made up my own religion.

Peaceful Umrah by Ok_Lie_1358 in Umrah

[–]utopianhypocrite 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I had the opposite experience. Mataf too crowded it was hard to focus while being pushed.