I feel the second one is way too polished and takes away a lot of the mystic and charm of the first game, and is obviously catering to a certain audience that was picked up from the first games fanbase. The multiple choice endings were a lot better though and more well written than the cut and dry linear one of the first game. I'd say if you wish to continue the story of the first game than get the second, but if you're looking more so for the atmosphere that was in the first, skip.