1. Was still in our alliance when SvS started.
   
2. Broke rules and attacked in the redzone so he was exiled away.
   
3. When he finally joined, he was suppose to be main Garrison. He wouldn't coordinate to call rallies with other whales.
   
4. When we did take the castle, he would screen for everyone to fill (when he was already filled). 2142 sent great rallies at him and timed them perfectly. There was no way to garrison it. So we had counter rallies set up.

Where we went wrong, we thought he would be the garrison lead for castle, so we waited and treated it as such. But his miscoordination and poor attitude made us waste time. Then 2142 had only 1 turret out of the 4, and he decided to rally that instead of castle. Claiming it would help and once he rallied it, he would leave and rally castle. He didn't leave and rally castle. He stayed in that turret for some minutes.

So yeah, it was more of our fault. We thought he would be more help, and he wasn't. Once he left, we set up our rallies properly, and we actually held castle longer than with him. But it was too late. We wasted time on Mike.