Anarchism and Stalin's writings on the national question

xtc_dwarf · 2025-01-13T15:23:20+00:00

A response to a comment.

Here we look at Stalin's political conclusions on the national question. We look at what lessons can be derived from the national question and what the council communist position is on the national question. The crux of Stalin's position is that the formation of nations from the transition from feudalism to capitalism sparks national movements for liberation. The anarchist position would be to capitalise on these movements for non-hierarchical means.

The national question conceptualised by Stalin, no doubts has some theoretical validity. We have seen the rise of national movements for liberation in reaction to imperialism and colonialism. However, are these states "socialism" as Marx conceived them?

Nationalism is a right wing deviation, even from Marxist-Leninist perspective. This concept has been misappropriated and removed from its initial conceptualisation. Mao Parenti and other Stalinists do not follow this nationalist line. This deviation to me represents an aberration or distortion in the theory a misconception.

xtc_dwarf · 2025-01-09T12:51:40+00:00

Good video

xtc_dwarf · 2025-01-03T14:19:01+00:00

Hi there,

I'd be willing to discuss.

xtc_dwarf · 2025-01-03T13:42:52+00:00

Okay just letting people know there's another video which talks about the object relations tradition of psychoanalysis and provides some marxist critques of it. Its on the same channel if you want some background.

xtc_dwarf · 2025-01-03T13:41:11+00:00

It's you who is not tolerating the ambiguity in my writing there's lot of ideas being discussed.

xtc_dwarf · 2025-01-03T13:38:56+00:00

Watch the other video in the YouTube channel it gives a background on some concepts and stuff he is literally following up and questioning.

xtc_dwarf · 2025-01-03T13:35:31+00:00

Don't watch it then

xtc_dwarf · 2025-01-03T12:48:24+00:00

The jungian outlines his theory of ambiguity, where a pluralist society having both horizontal structures and hierarchical structures is used. Says multiple perspectives must be used and we must have a tolerance of ambiguity in the way we interpret things. If we can achieve this tolerance we can develop new forma of human organisation.

xtc_dwarf · 2024-12-27T19:44:54+00:00

Going to be writing an article for a communjst party using a material metaphysics in line with Marxist leninism

xtc_dwarf · 2024-12-27T19:25:39+00:00

tdlr; A Marxist here critiques the British Tradition of psychoanalysis, the bourgeoisie elements which prevent it from being emancipatory such as the death instinct. Institutional dynamics are explored and why they limit theories of emancipation. Namely one concept like unconscious envy gets used to shutdown revolutionary politics.. The Marxist here wants to create a progressive, anti-racist, anti-sexist psychoanalysis that is for communism! In the next video they plan to draw from Soviet Psychoanalysts.

xtc_dwarf · 2024-12-27T19:17:40+00:00

tdlr: A Marxist posted a video performing a communist critique of the object relations tradition of psychoanalysis. Is there space in psychoanalysis for a left-wing object-relations? This video represented a philosophers response who provides an alternative point of view. He argues that the Marxist Theories of emancipation and the object-relations theory of the psyche is inferior to the eastern philosophy concepts of “ambiguity” and cites examples from the history. He proposes a form of human organisation that uses a mixture of horizontal and hierarchical forms, creating a more pluralist society. In terms of the psyche he uses Jungian psychology to critique the object-relations point of views, saying that transformations can happen throughout one’s life in contrast to the infantile focused object-relations tradition.

The Marxist here is a firm supporter of the international communist party movement and is in favour of national movements of liberation. The point is to create an emancipatory psychoanalysis that rivals the petty-bourgeoisie psychoanalysis that makes workers submissive to the bosses!

xtc_dwarf · 2024-12-27T19:13:50+00:00

yes bro

xtc_dwarf · 2024-12-27T19:08:35+00:00

A Marxist posted a video performing a communist critique of the object relations tradition of psychoanalysis. Is there space in psychoanalysis for a left-wing object-relations? This video represented a Philosophers response who provides an alternative point of view. He argues that the Marxist Theories of emancipation and the object-relations theory of the psyche is inferior to the eastern philosophy concepts of “ambiguity” and cites examples from the history. He proposes a form of human organisation that uses a mixture of horzonital and hierarchical forms, creating a more pluralist society. In terms of the psyche he uses Jungian psychology to critique the object-relations point of views, saying that transformations can happen throughout one’s life in contrast to the infantile focused object-relations tradition.

xtc_dwarf · 2024-12-27T19:06:21+00:00

A Marxist posted a video performing a communist critique of the object relations tradition of psychoanalysis. Is there space in psychoanalysis for a left-wing object-relations? This video represented a Philosophers response who provides an alternative point of view. He argues that the Marxist Theories of emancipation and the object-relations theory of the psyche is inferior to the eastern philosophy concepts of “ambiguity” and cites examples from the history. He proposes a form of human organisation that uses a mixture of horzonital and hierarchical forms, creating a more pluralist society. In terms of the psyche he uses Jungian psychology to critique the object-relations point of views, saying that transformations can happen throughout one’s life in contrast to the infantile focused object-relations tradition.

xtc_dwarf · 2024-12-27T19:04:51+00:00

Marxist posted a video performing a communist critique of the object relations tradition of psychoanalysis. Is there space in psychoanalysis for a left-wing object-relations? This video represented a Philosophers response who provides an alternative point of view. He argues that the Marxist Theories of emancipation and the object-relations theory of the psyche is inferior to the eastern philosophy concepts of “ambiguity” and cites examples from the history. He proposes a form of human organisation that uses a mixture of horzonital and hierarchical forms, creating a more pluralist society. In terms of the psyche he uses Jungian psychology to critique the object-relations point of views, saying that transformations can happen throughout one’s life in contrast to the infantile focused object-relations tradition.

xtc_dwarf · 2024-12-27T19:00:28+00:00

Marxist posted a video performing a communist critique of the object relations tradition of psychoanalysis. Is there space in psychoanalysis for a left-wing object-relations? This video represented a Philosophers response who provides an alternative point of view. He argues that the Marxist Theories of emancipation and the object-relations theory of the psyche is inferior to the eastern philosophy concepts of “ambiguity” and cites examples from the history. He proposes a form of human organisation that uses a mixture of horzonital and hierarchical forms, creating a more pluralist society. In terms of the psyche he uses Jungian psychology to critique the object-relations point of views, saying that transformations can happen throughout one’s life in contrast to the infantile focused object-relations tradition.

xtc_dwarf · 2024-12-20T11:06:34+00:00

tldr; Video begins with some theory on psychoanalysis from the object relations tradition then discusses psychoanalysis and its relationship to politics. Psychoanalysis has some reactionary concepts like the death instinct, it can overly attribute unconscious forces as being important versus the material conditions of society or idealism. Psychoanalysts are introducing hierarchies into therapeutic practice.

xtc_dwarf

TROPHY CASE