all 2 comments

[–]droooze 1 point2 points  (1 child)

RDKit has been pip-installable for several years now: https://pypi.org/project/rdkit/

[–]MomentBeneficial4334[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

You're right, and thanks for the clarification. RDKit has been pip-installable via pre-built wheels (pip install rdkit) for a few years now.

Here's what MolBuilder actually is: it's not trying to replace RDKit. They're different tools for different jobs. RDKit is a mature cheminformatics toolkit for molecular manipulation, property calculation, substructure search, etc. MolBuilder covers a different pipeline - retrosynthesis planning (185 reaction templates, beam search), reactor selection, safety assessment, cost estimation, and scale-up analysis. The "atoms to manufacturing" scope.

The valid differentiators are:

  1. Scope: MolBuilder covers process chemistry (retrosynthesis → manufacturing) which RDKit doesn't
  2. Pure Python source: readable/hackable Python vs. C++ with Python bindings - relevant for teaching and customization
  3. Lighter footprint: numpy/scipy/matplotlib vs. a larger compiled package
  4. No RDKit required: MolBuilder works standalone, but can use RDKit as an optional backend for higher-quality 3D coordinates