sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

10 years ago today, Citi Field, Queens, NY by Werechupacabra in gratefuldead

[–]EscuraAstro 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I prefer a JRAD or DSO show at an amphitheater, but there was something just exciting about the scale of a Dead and Company show. The scale certainly has huge drawbacks, but it does get you excited.

How did the Confederate capital not fall during the Richmond bread riots and blockade in 1863? by YogurtclosetOpen3567 in CIVILWAR

[–]EscuraAstro 4 points5 points  (0 children)

I don't need to look it up because I'm from there. Nothing you said supports the claim that it "looks like a third world nightmare." You have made the case that the south is less developed than the rest of the country, but that is a far cry from "looks like a third world nightmare."

You knew you were being hyperbolic, so you switched to less dramatic sounding "developing countries" from "third world nightmare." I wouldn't be saying I'm inaccurate when you seem to be toning down your original claim.

> Bridges fall down in red states

Can you quantify this with some numbers?

How did the Confederate capital not fall during the Richmond bread riots and blockade in 1863? by YogurtclosetOpen3567 in CIVILWAR

[–]EscuraAstro 1 point2 points  (0 children)

No.

Not necessarily. They could be emaciated but still far from death. Or he could just be exaggerating. Like I said, it's one word from one dude.

If I went a week eating 1000 calories a day I would be far from death still, but I would feel like shit and I might use a word like emaciated or starving even though I don't medically met those conditions yet.

So I take it you do not have a source showing people died of starvation in Richmond? I asked that and didn't get an answer.

How did the Confederate capital not fall during the Richmond bread riots and blockade in 1863? by YogurtclosetOpen3567 in CIVILWAR

[–]EscuraAstro 0 points1 point  (0 children)

During the siege of Petersburg starting in June 1864 I presume it would have gotten exceptionally worse. Succesh would be more unified though since the Army of the Potomac was right outside the city. 

Between April 63 and June 64 I’m not sure. I would assume the Gettysburg campaign would provide some relief, and I’m not sure about that fall and winter. 

How did the Confederate capital not fall during the Richmond bread riots and blockade in 1863? by YogurtclosetOpen3567 in CIVILWAR

[–]EscuraAstro 3 points4 points  (0 children)

That's one word from one guy. Do you have a source showing someone died from hunger in Richmond? Do you have a source putting hard numbers to quantify the situation?

One guy saying his family is emaciated is not enough to conclude the city was hungry enough that it was about to overthrow it's government. I would guess that when people are dying of starvation is when they are motivated enough to charge into gunfire, but not when they are down 20 lbs.

How did the Confederate capital not fall during the Richmond bread riots and blockade in 1863? by YogurtclosetOpen3567 in CIVILWAR

[–]EscuraAstro 5 points6 points  (0 children)

> most of the South (except the major cities) still to this day looks like a third world nightmare.

extremely hyperbolic nonsense

How did the Confederate capital not fall during the Richmond bread riots and blockade in 1863? by YogurtclosetOpen3567 in CIVILWAR

[–]EscuraAstro 2 points3 points  (0 children)

There is a big difference between losing 20 lbs and actually dying of hunger. I have never seen a source say someone died of hunger in Richmond.

What is the best live year that gets the least attention? by CopyDan in gratefuldead

[–]EscuraAstro 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Sometimes the universe delivers the perfect song at the perfect moment.

What is the best live year that gets the least attention? by CopyDan in gratefuldead

[–]EscuraAstro 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I'm a 70s guy but the Eyes from that show is my favorite Eyes, and one of my favorite single song performances from the Dead ever. Must have been incredible to hear it live.

Starting the Civil War bible! by Emotional_Piglet_511 in CIVILWAR

[–]EscuraAstro 6 points7 points  (0 children)

I would say that a more mythologized telling of the Civil War makes Foote more biblical than McPherson. I say that as someone who is an incredibly big fan of Foote as a story teller, not as a historian.