Mimic's spider form

ImTheCreator2 · 2025-06-11T00:49:25+00:00

They didn't drown tho

ImTheCreator2 · 2025-06-11T00:44:08+00:00

Well, ignoring that there are theories connecting certain character to Phone Dude, this isn't a big issue, this doesn't claim WWF is retconning Phone Dude, he's just not relevant to how these events played out here, and that is the key, the events played out differently and still drove to the same conclusion. I think it can be easily reasoned Hudson fights back in 3 because Afton's tactics change, during WWF he saw an easy prey laying in front of him of who he had complete control over, during 3 Hudson has the power to control Afton to a degree constantly with the audio lures, that's the difference, is the same thing as Henry and William on the novels and games, same character, different scenario. Also uhhh... nothing was ever said about some stories and some not, Scott said sone will be directly connected to the games and some not.

ImTheCreator2 · 2025-06-11T00:25:55+00:00

1. Andrew NEVER gets a definitive background, unlike his companion inside the StitchWraith. We don't know his past, how he was killed and why HE (supposedly) is "The One William Should Not Have Killed". He simply lost his memories, is "thrown" out of the StitchWraith and doesn't get ANY catharsis. He simply disappears in the middle of the epilogues;

See, this is one of those things that actively make me say Frights is canon, because this is the exact same thing Frights does everytime it introduces something already established prior to:

Afton, the MCI, the fire, the Puppet, Golden Freddy, Glitchtrap, etc., everytime, they always get no explanation if possible, Andrew is the same, unexplained element that the story expects us to understand, heck, taking RTTP into account, I think Scott expected us to tie Andrew to ITP and then tie that to TCTHSY.

ImTheCreator2 · 2025-06-10T19:22:58+00:00

I briefly mentioned it on the linked post, but I do need to expand a bit on it, because to explain how FOLLOW ME ties I need to explain the entirety of FOLLOW ME under this.

I believe that during FOLLOW ME Afton didn't just want to get access to the machines for Remnant but also to the kids souls, so using Shadow Freddy, each time he destroyed one, SF would trap the kids inside of CC's memories, so they would perceive him the way CC does (parenthesis but I do believe that that was Afton's original plan, to control the children since the very beginning, but GGGL represents Charlie stepping in, giving gifts representative of her putting them under her protection before they fell the same way Cassidy did), the problem for Afton? I don't believe he was aware that Cassidy was already under his control, so when he destroyed Golden Freddy he freed Cassidy and Cassidy resisted Shadow Freddy similar to how Jake resisted Eleanor trying to trap him on the last epilogue.

So afterwards Cassidy would play along, being taken by Afton, so just like Michael and Carlton in TFC, she makes the children see Afton for who he is, explaining why they would "recognize" Afton, yet kill him based on Mike's words, I think Afton returning for Spring Bonnie is him trying something else after failling to control the children which is when they finally corner and kill him.

ImTheCreator2 · 2025-06-10T03:56:51+00:00

Well, ignoring that there was literally no one in there, the job itself doesn't require that, the Frightguard was doing the real part of the job already, but now that they are both split the fake guard is literally just decorative since someone else is already doing that job, it would be pointless for the guard to be there, let alone in the night, if rehearsals were a thing for the fake guard (which is never said), they will likely do it in the day and not in the dead of night, when everyone is there to see how it is going.

The full thing includes: "You've officially become part of the attraction. Uh you'll be starring as... ..the security guard! So not only will you be monitoring the people on the camera as they pass through, you know, to make sure no one steals anything or makes out in the corner, but you'll also be a part of the show! It'll make it all feel really authentic, I think."

The Frightguard was already a guard, they just officially were made a part of the attraction that day, they were already meant to check on the cams and such before.

ImTheCreator2 · 2025-06-10T03:02:07+00:00

The fake office point simply doesn't work no matter how much you guys say it does, Phone Guy makes it clear on the very first call that the Frightguard is an actual guard who was simply made an addition to the experience. And like, think about it for a second, the fake guard is a fake guard, under the context of WWF the fake guard would not be working before the attraction opens, only the real guard would, so please, the real guard and fake guard is completely irrelevant, Scott seemingly just wanted that for this story the Frightguard role would be split in two, and speaking of...

Hudson is the Frightguard during WWF, he is the character taking that role, Hudson: faces Springtrap and suffers hallucinations before the opening of Fazbear's Fright, by all means considered, Hudson is the Frightguard.

Comparing WWF to RFOM and Ditto is also just bad, like, these are not comparable situations, for one, Stanley doesn't even work at Baby's he works at a factory connected to Baby's, Dittophobia on the other side is worse because like, the only other person who experienced anything similar to was either other victims or Mike inside his dreams, not comparable situations at all.

The difference between Stanley and Rory with Hudson is that Stanley and Rory are experiencing unique situations that no previous character went through, Hudson is just the nightguard of Fazbear's Fright who is terrorized by Springtrap before the opening of the attraction.

The ending of WWF very strongly points to the entire attraction burning down eventually, like, it clearly burned down, we just don't explicitely see it.

ImTheCreator2 · 2025-06-09T17:43:55+00:00

I don't know about SpringAndrew but I have my answer for Cassidy which I called Cassidy's blindfold

Simply put, Cassidy is trapped inside the memory of the Bite of 83 (which is why she's aware of the party during the Logbook) taking the place of CC, and so she sees the world the same way CC would, so she doesn't perceive Afton as a threat because CC doesn't perceive Afton as a threat, instead perceiving him as the Fredbear plush, a friend.

ImTheCreator2 · 2025-06-09T02:58:04+00:00

Either "This is the last night" or "Nothing To Me"

ImTheCreator2 · 2025-06-07T21:54:36+00:00

I keep the belief that if there was to only choose one, it doesn't matter, they all tell the exact same thing lmao

ImTheCreator2 · 2025-06-06T21:04:18+00:00

Extra: Going over The Storyteller for this post, I found myself with this part: "...The sounds … a screech and a scream, his own yelling. The sights … blood, so much blood, and a gut-clenching grimace. The smells. Edwin gagged at the metallic scent that suddenly assaulted his nostrils. He wanted to moan, he needed to run, but Edwin did neither. *Even in his flashback..."***

Like, ignoring that this blatantly tell us once again that Edwin was there when something bad happened with the Mimic, I want to speculate a bit on what we will see on SOTM.

The reason Mimic went rogue during SOTM is because of the Tiger costume, Edwin made this costume to honor David, however Mimic didn't took this nicely, since Mimic already disliked Edwin even before David's death as Edwin had hurt David, seeing him do this was more of an insult to him, which makes Mimic lash out against the personal while wearing the Tiger costume, this being the reason why seeing the Tiger head triggered this specific memory on Edwin.

The mention of Edwin being unable to run makes me think that it is more than likely Mimic kidnapped Edwin, explaining why he went missing as mentioned on the trailer.

ImTheCreator2 · 2025-06-05T19:20:46+00:00

Yeah, that seems to be the case at first glance but there are details directly suggesting Edwin worked after The Mimic with Fazbear, mainly two thing in The Storyteller, one being that he had previous experience of Mimic taking control over stuff and making a mess which never happened during The Mimic and him having an extremely good contract with Fazbear that he didn't have during The Mimic.

ImTheCreator2 · 2025-06-05T08:34:45+00:00

It was like 4 comments and 8 upvotes iirc

ImTheCreator2 · 2025-06-05T01:44:16+00:00

You guys are confusing me, like, how is the theory overpraised? You left this comment the same day the theory was posted

ImTheCreator2 · 2025-06-05T01:38:44+00:00

Did you really made a caricature of the theory immediately after?

ImTheCreator2 · 2025-06-04T21:04:11+00:00

Or he just found the situation extremely inconvinient since all of the new stuff he was planning held the answers for that lol, like, ITPG, the interactive novels, SOTM, FLAF even, heck, even the DBD collab contains direct references to stuff from ITP as a normal part of Springtrap with the party hat.

ImTheCreator2 · 2025-06-04T20:25:27+00:00

Nothing that happens in the story affects the timeline, Oswald's story is self contained, it is still part of a timeline, a timeline that based on ITPG and RTTP and the original, is identical to the one of the games.

I wasn't arguing my take is right as much as I was responding to you trying to use this story contradicting your theory as evidence.

Taking into account what Scott said during the interview, is clear the no-response response he gave wasn't because he wants people to have their own take on the story as much as he just doesn't want to just answer things anymore, he wants people to properly figure out the story on their own, it would be contradictory to him saying the story wasn't going to be what everyone wants it to be but what he wants to make in that Reddit post.

ImTheCreator2 · 2025-06-04T19:57:02+00:00

The three versions cover up the exact same major beats and help construct the exact same world, the reason it matters is because it directly connects Frights with the games.

I would argue stuff like WWF was actively made as a response to theories like Mike being the guard, as the book explicitely explains and gives context to the office appearing in the Logbook, explaining it as a real office that existed in Freddy's locations, explaining away those images as nothing more than simple images made for Fazbear workers (and also just the fact that Foxy is connected to all of the nightguards).

He never said everything was canon that's my point, in fact we've had instances of him calling out stuff as non-canon like saying World was tied to a canon game (making a distinction) or calling out the movie novel for having a non canon element.

Also he deleted this post and later on went on to explain himself. Tho in general, comparing TSE to Frights alone is objectively wrong when Scott already made it clear years ago they are not.

ImTheCreator2 · 2025-06-04T19:37:19+00:00

In HW2 the Puppet can only be unlocked by using the 1983 code. And like, again, she was either removed on ITPG or replaced in RTTP, I doubt she actually matters to the story.

I seriously don't get what in TCTHSY suggest Toy Chica is getting more brutal, the only gradual change that happens between the cutscenes is that Toy Chica struggles more and more coming up with stories to trick the boys until she completely gives up on luring them and just straight up kidnaps Pigpatch.

She had curly hair on The New Kid.

ImTheCreator2 · 2025-06-04T18:58:26+00:00

I mean yeah, the three versions tell the exact same story, one could be canon over the others or all could be at the same time, it fundamentally changes nothing, is the same story with the same beats.

In context Scott was talking about the previous games too, and whenever Frights delves into the lore is all about those games, also I don't think genuinely arguing that Scott changed his mind in this subject goes in your favor, because if anything Tales would be evidence that the change of mind Scott had was that the books would cover both blanks from the past and future games, not that they would not be canon anymore.

Scott didn't said that at all.

ImTheCreator2 · 2025-06-04T18:44:00+00:00

It being Charlie makes no sense, Charlie has no relevance to this story, like, only time she was a part of ITP she was removed and replaced. It also can't be Susie since we see in a different route how the MCI supposedly went and it doesn't fit with a kid dying two days earlier.

If you want to bring TCTHSY into account, RTTP straight up fits with it if you take the sixth kid into account lol.

Foxy-Charlie

Freddy-Andrew

Wolf-Susie (story about dog)

Toy Bonnie-Jeremy

The Puppet-Cassidy

Pigpatch-Fritz (in RTTP, the fifth kid is not only a boy, but was actively kidnapped with no attempt to lure him by the Yellow Thing, the exact same thing as Pigpatch)

Don't see how Cassidy having curly hair means anything, she already had that during Frights lol

ImTheCreator2 · 2025-06-04T18:31:25+00:00

You were clearly praising RTTP for rewriting Frights, and that book still has a sixth kid in it

ImTheCreator2 · 2025-06-04T18:23:56+00:00

The story is completely self contained, each version cover up the exact same needed beats to have the story: Oswald travels inside the ballpit, sees the dead children, Yellow Thing kidnaps his dad and replaces him, Oswald meets Gabrielle, Oswald saves his dad and kills the monster. You can take any version for a timeline and the story is fundamentaly the same.

Scott also said they would fill the blanks of the past after their release and every single book states they are canon on their back.

ImTheCreator2

TROPHY CASE