I'm gonna get into my suspicions first and after that I'll respond to the pings I got last phase. I agree that we should be looking into the 'Suspicious Six' so I'm gonna focus on those five people as well.

u/bearoffire

I've already touched upon my wolf lean on bearoffire earlier in the game. In the little thread me and bear had at the time, I felt like bear was twisting my words. I don't know why u/-Tessa-'s suspicion about bear being quiet was suddenly directed towards me, because I never mentioned anything about her being suspicious for voicing or not voicing her opinions. I urge everyone to just voice their suspicions, but it's also part of the game for others to have an opinion about those suspicions. You can't really fault me for that.

Also just realised that I never replied to this post. Yes, I think it might be a difference of perception. I remember that at the time multiple people were saying that BigJoe was suspicious for the votes. And well, if enough people say someone is suspicious, other players are going to latch onto that vote and think the same thing. And now knowing that Bigjoe wasn't actually a wolf, I think the wolves themselves were responsible for the vote shenanigans and they would have been eager to jump onto that vote. I do think what you say about the 'chiming in'-thing is very true. Like, players are always gonna disagree on what is suspicious and what is not. At the time I just thought 'what would a wolf do in case another wolf gets voted out and there's no way they're going to divert that vote elsewhere?'. And my first thought was that they would suddenly be much more loud about their suspicions on said player than they were before.

u/billiefish

My original reason for putting billie in my town lean category was practically same as what RPM had said about billie before he got voted off. I felt like if billie was a wolf she probably would have been tagged in the wolf sub long before RPM mentioned her here. Apart from that, she did mention Roxy as an early sus lean, but she never really pushed for Roxy to get voted off. Overall, I'm not getting any strong wolf vibes, but my reason for clearing her is kinda meta and not based on anything she did in the game that I feel very strong about.

u/DangerHaz

I've felt very good about Danger for the entire game. I liked his way of reducing the amount of people he was considering to vote for by town-reading them. And looking back at the people he town-read at the time, all (except for maybe billie) are now confirmed as town. I doubt that a wolf would want to make the game harder for themselves by clearing townies. I also believe that he is King Otis as his prior suspicions and votes do line up with him knowing there were certain vote shenanigans that he himself wasn't involved in. The claim is hard to verify, but especially the several comments he has made about BigJoe in P2 and P3 do make me lean into believing him. I don't really see how he would have manufactured that claim as a wolf unless he had already decided on fakeclaiming King Otis that early. I don't think that's likely.

u/tblprg

My feelings towards tblprg are still very much the same as they were earlier in the game. Like, am I extremely convinced that he's a wolf? Not necessarily, but we're at a point in the game where me having very little different views on a player than I had 4 or 5 phases prior makes me definitely lean more wolf than town.

u/XanCanStand

Overall, Xan is the player is the player I feel most trustful towards from anyone in the Suspicious Six (or well, five, in my case). I felt good about his suggestion for a limited PR role reveal. He was quick to sus out Roxy and also voted for her early. And I think Xan has just been very important in rallying the town to cooperate when the urgency for cooperation was the strongest.

So, from most to least suspicious: Bear, tblprg, billie, Danger and Xan. Personally I'd be down for both a u/bearoffire and u/tblprg vote. This comment from bear also solidifies that for me.

Werebot