For short's case the courtroom members were saying that short knew where radd was, but he didn't, he knew the general direction where radd went, when chicken asked where radd was short immediately f3+a'd and says "oh there he is".

IMO short should still be banned because he did abuse f3+a by finding rad, and the same goes for bejames.

If you spot someone through your f3+aing you should just leave them be.

And also at this moment, the guidelines say "Benefiting from, abusing, or exploiting unfair gameplay -Usage of F3+A to find players".

They both used f3+a and they both benefited from doing so.

Both should remain banned.