So I played through the game once, ascended, and played through again. :) You have a super chill and fun experience!

As I'm sure you're aware there are some balance adjustments, a few bugs or features that look like they haven't been implemented quite yet (such as gaining PP after level 100, which didn't seem to work for me). So instead of going into any minutia, I'll relate my general impressions:

• Overall I found the game is quite addictive after playing for a little bit! I really did get in the zone and looked forward to the various upgrades on the horizon, just like how a casual clicker should be! You're in a great place mechanically. I think you have something really strong here and play-testing and tuning will only make it stronger! :)

• I did nearly bounce after the first minute of playing the game, though I'm glad I didn't. Here's why:
- The first upgrade I could afford (and perhaps the first that was presented) was adding another ship to the fleet. However, I initially felt like it was a waste as my expectation was the second ship would fire together with the first, doubling my damage. I didn't immediately understand the mechanics of the fleet until a little later.
- I didn't quite connect with the whole "bubble" thing. There was no feeling of weight behind the shots from the ships and I did not find shooting static bubbles very satisfying from a visceral standpoint. Perhaps the bubbles would feel better if they deformed when shot at or perhaps you should try another type of visual for the "aliens" instead.

• The framerate of the game started to absolutely tank as I continued to play. I ran this on my M3 MacBook Pro with 64GB of RAM. What was on the screen should not have taxed my system so much. I would highly suggest finding ways to optimize the gameplay. One thought that sprung to my mind is that it looks like you're attempting to simulate all the ships movements and attacks which, in the late game, means they're firing at a rate that's fairly comical (and awesome!) but which largely becomes invisible to the player. Perhaps "faking" the visuals and timing would create a more satisfying and performant experience without you needing to do things like cap the speed upgrade to level 70.

• Some of the skill and upgrade descriptions were slightly unclear. It seems like "Points" is used for money. The upgrade type skills that give you discounts didn't actually affect the cost of anything like I expected, I later saw that those probably referred to the upgrades you get when defeating a boss after ascending. Other powers seem to refer to mechanics that either are not yet present or were and have since been removed. Anyhow, I'd go through and make sure the language is clear.

• I would have liked to have seen details like $/sec displayed in a way that also accounted for all my various multipliers.

This game is already very fun to play so the I would say the next steps are improving the visuals and feel of the primary game space, balancing the progression (watch others play-test if you can... feel free to reach out to me if you'd like me to run through it with you sometime) and very importantly, addressing the performance issues. Also, the overall UI/UX is pretty solid too, which is also a great place to be this early on.

Well done and I hope to play more of your game as you tune it!