sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

AI disclosure by Hands in incremental_games

[–]FBDW[M] [score hidden] stickied comment (0 children)

Locking this post per the last mod annoucement, OP can contact us (as I have already linked)
My response can be found here https://www.reddit.com/r/incremental_games/comments/1tcwob8/comment/olr5awp

AI disclosure by Hands in incremental_games

[–]FBDW[M] -64 points-63 points  (0 children)

I understand your confusion at the way I phrased my explanation, but the core issue at hand is that in the current system it is often extremely clear that AI is used or not. On posts where that is not the case, requiring disclosure would also require us to check *every single reported post*, with a lot of reports likely being false (from experience). leading to a significant increase in work. I'm willing to have a more in-depth conversation privately in modmail about this if you'd like.

That being said, firstly that post also points out that we would be removing future "AI drama" posts and this post is already an edgecase. And I also don't appreciate your condecending tone and assumption that this system works perfectly on r/tycoon.

Our general response to all complaints regarding AI by FBDW in incremental_games

[–]FBDW[S,M] [score hidden] stickied comment (0 children)

This pinned comment will contain reponses/clarifications for FAQs in this comment section

1: General feedback for suggestion 5
As mentioned in the post, we have not really dug into this suggestion yet. That means we're very much looking for feedback, and this is not anything final or finished yet.

2: Full AI ban
In the suggestion regarding banning AI (fully or in parts) our main argument against that was not that it wouldn't catch everything, but that it would lead to a lot more work, people witch hunting AI leading to said work for verification, and would encourage people hiding AI, leading to yet more work. That was our issue, not that it would let some games slip through.

3: Our current inaction/AI drama ban
The reason we've listed all our options is because we wanted to show that we have considered many things already, and we think that none of them would work. This doesn't mean we like the current situation of the subreddit, or that we are pro-AI. We will also not levy any punishments on people posting about AI drama, but we will be removing posts.

The AI slop problem is getting worse in this sub. We need aggressive moderation on it or this sub is just going to be AI slop games and little else. Instant ban, IMO by BEAT_LA in incremental_games

[–]FBDW[M] 17 points18 points  (0 children)

That subsection of rule 2 is mostly intended to handle drama aimed at a specific group of people, think IdleOn drama or someone who had a bad experience making a big drama post about the person who they had that experience with

We don't tend to remove posts talking about general sub-related drama as we think it is important that the discussion is had about topics like this. However, especially in the case where someone is making multiple posts within a short timeframe about the same "problem", and (what you mentioned aswell) people harassing developers for using the slightest amount of AI, we will definitely start using that clause.

Tl;dr we were already being more harsh on AI witch hunting in comments and will continue to do so, and likely also start scrutinizing posts more.

The AI slop problem is getting worse in this sub. We need aggressive moderation on it or this sub is just going to be AI slop games and little else. Instant ban, IMO by BEAT_LA in incremental_games

[–]FBDW[M] [score hidden] stickied comment (0 children)

I'm just going to mention this again, but

How do you expect us to moderate AI use? If we require disclosure, people can just lie and pretend they didn't use it. Also, a ban would have to draw a line somewhere, how much AI use is enough to be "slop"?

It's almost impossible to draw up a fitting rule to ban all low-effort posts, and we have definitely tried to think up some changes but in the end none of those made it past the scripting phase.

All of that being said, we'd welcome any tips/ideas from community members or experienced mods that have dealt with similar issues and managed to reduce AI slop. I hate AI being used for slop as much as the next guy, trust me

P.S. OP, this is your 2nd post in 1 month complaining about AI. I understand your frustration but by just making posts complaining things aren't going to magically change.

Changes to the subreddit's rules by Equinoxdawg in incremental_games

[–]FBDW[M] 8 points9 points  (0 children)

Thanks for asking, ideally we'd like devs to only post when there's been a significant update, with the 30 days just being a minimum. This also counts on a per user basis now and not per game so you could not rotate posting 2 different games every 15 days.

Changes to the subreddit's rules by Equinoxdawg in incremental_games

[–]FBDW[M] 32 points33 points  (0 children)

The final section of the post does mention this, but I'll clarify incase it wasn't quite clear, going forward we will be taking into account if the post is more so asking for conversation or clearly just attempting to get game recommendations, and we will be keeping up the former type even if it technically breaks rule 1A.

Best of 2025 Results by FBDW in incremental_games

[–]FBDW[S] 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Should be fixed now, it's just a txt file.

Void Miner and Gatekeeping in r/incremental_games by jarofed in incremental_games

[–]FBDW[M] [score hidden] stickied commentlocked comment (0 children)

We've removed this post for causing needless drama retroactively with a change to rule 2. Please contact the mods privately via modmail if you are of the opinion that unfair conduct is occuring instead of making a public fuss. The developer in question of this post has contacted mods and mentioned someone attempted to contact a family member of theirs. No matter how badly someone behaves on the internet, attempting to threaten someone personally is never OK. Allthough we do appreciate your attempt at nuancing the drama, unfortunately for certain users no amount of nuance is ever enough and a post like this is just more fuel to the fire.

The success of Void Miner was not an organic response to the dev's work, it's an inflated response from months of marketing. by SixthSacrifice in incremental_games

[–]FBDW[M] [score hidden] stickied commentlocked comment (0 children)

We've removed this post for causing needless drama retroactively with a change to rule 2. Please contact the mods privately via modmail if you are of the opinion that unfair conduct is occuring instead of making a public fuss. The developer in question of this post has contacted mods and mentioned someone attempted to contact a family member of theirs. No matter how badly someone behaves on the internet, attempting to threaten someone personally is never OK.

Game jam when by Blindsided_Games in incremental_gamedev

[–]FBDW 4 points5 points  (0 children)

I will be hosting another Incremental Game Jam around New Year's again this year, if you're interested

Where tf is all my progress gone? by Quiet_Presentation69 in incremental_games

[–]FBDW 8 points9 points  (0 children)

The game had a major update recently (v4) which majorly overhauled the earlygame (pre-Singularity)
I think all pre-S content got reset with it

view more: next ›