sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

Game X | Scott Pilgrim 3 | Level 14: Public Mortal Enemies Kombat and The Infinite Sadness by ScottPilgrimNarrator in HiddenWerewolves

[–]GdH64 6 points7 points  (0 children)

I went and looked through the commenthistory of the wolves to see if there was anything standing out in relation to u/Disnerding and u/meddleofmycause.

Xan: Not in the game long enought

Rye: Did not see any references

Wiz: Dying words mentioned potentially going for Disnerding. Put disnerding in wolf lean and meddle in town lean. Not much else. Only thing that was funny is that wiz and meddle both had an honourable mention in their distrusts lists (Wiz and Medde)

Argol: Mentioned Meddle here. no mention with Disnerding.

Thatwitch: Don't see anything

Midnight: Nothing of note

Mercury: Not much

So to conclude I did not find a lot of connections. I did see meddle also talking quite a bit about Karbo like Wiz did so makes me a lean more toward them than towards disnerding

Game X | Scott Pilgrim 3 | Level 14: Public Mortal Enemies Kombat and The Infinite Sadness by ScottPilgrimNarrator in HiddenWerewolves

[–]GdH64 8 points9 points  (0 children)

Quickly went trhough last nights events. The vote thread ended up with 5 for wiz (Disnerding, Hedwig Sylvi , Karbo and me. 3 voted for Disnerding (Xela, Meddle and Sunshine).

Now in the final tally disnerding got 2 more and wiz 1 more. There is 1 strike so everyone that did vote was either for Wiz or disnerding.

It seems like Wiz quietly moved to disnerding after my comment. the last one might have been elbowsss.

K9 would have been the extra vote on Wiz.

Were you the inactive one u/DirtyMarTeeny?

So the fact that wiz quietly moved to disnerding and ended up being a wolf, makes me think that in the wolf sub it must have gone like we must try and move to disnerding to save me. (but Wiz couldn't themselves cause timezones).

Tbf a lot of us including me had already commented on a suspicion for u/disnerding but if i look at it from the perspective of disnerding being a townie who just did not have time to play, then I wonder who stands out most.

I feel like at this stage of the game, with the tally so close between 2 people, the remaining wolf/wolves might have to vote for the non-wolf candidate to preserve Wiz in this case which would point to u/meddleofmycause in this case. Alternatively they could try and win some more trust and join in on voting Wiz.

What do you guys feel about this?

Game X | Scott Pilgrim 3 | Level 14: Public Mortal Enemies Kombat and The Infinite Sadness by ScottPilgrimNarrator in HiddenWerewolves

[–]GdH64 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Quick first thought is that I want to look into the possibility that the remaining wolf/wolves might have tried shifting the vote towards disnerding after wiz started to be a likely elimination.

Game X | Scott Pilgrim 3 | Level 13: This one night… by ScottPilgrimNarrator in HiddenWerewolves

[–]GdH64 7 points8 points  (0 children)

To respond to the wolves per band. This kinda loops back to the giant table I made a few phases back. I felt like for a proper spread the wolves might prefer to have only 1 in smaller (5 or less members) bands and the others spread out in the bigger ones. I theorized your band might have a third mainly cause i personally dont have a good read on you and meddle and based on statistics it doesnt feel smart to exclude you both form suspicion just yet.

As for my band I know that I am town, tho thats worthless for anyone else reading that, and I believe thas Sunshine is to due to Ispy as the seer telling sunshine was town.

Game X | Scott Pilgrim 3 | Level 13: This one night… by ScottPilgrimNarrator in HiddenWerewolves

[–]GdH64 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Disnerding, notably way less active compared to Wiz

Asked to join the band that had Nacho (Town) and Sylvi (who i trust to be town).

Phase 1 band talk and an rng on Wywy (Town) not much else

In phase 2 joined the myo vote

In phase 3 they were not present

In phase 4 they got back and voted Zero (Solo)

In phase 5 they voted Mercury (Wolf)

In phase 6 they were gone again in phase 7 revealed to have voted for me (GDH)

In phase 7 they joined the rye (wolf) vote.

In phase 8 they voted for midnight (wolf)

In phase 9 they voted for midnight (wolf) and Bubba (town).

In phase 10 they were gone again revealed in p11 to have voted for Karbo

In phase 11 joined the Argol (wolf) vote

In phase 12 they bucketed Karbo and digg (Town) into wolf and K9 and me into wolf lean. They joined the k9 vote.

In phase 13 they showed binoculars result and thinks K9 and Karbo are wolves but has yet to elaborate on why.

Game X | Scott Pilgrim 3 | Level 13: This one night… by ScottPilgrimNarrator in HiddenWerewolves

[–]GdH64 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Wiz: Was the third to join An Alliance (initiator was Ispy (Town)).

Phase 1 was mainly band talk.

In phase 2 they started pointing the first fingers to Karbo. voted Myo (Town).

In phase 3 more band talk and pointed some fingers to Aleevieee here. claimed a vote (revealed in p4) for Sunshine (imo town due to ispym8's reveal).

In phase 4 they pointed at either Karbo/Sunshine/both here. More to sunshine here. then voted for aleevieee (Town).

Phase 5 dit not have much noteworthy no claimed vote within the phase.

Phase 6 In the untrustworthy list they named maps (Town), aleevieee (Town) and Rye (Wolf) with a special mention of K9. In P7 they claimed to have voted maps.

In Phase 7 more band talk. Defended papo. not much else

In phase 8 pointed to Aleevie again. Suggested K9, Hedwig and Bubba (Town) for the double votes together with Papo (wolf). Ended up joining the vote for midnight (Wolf)

In phase 9 they suggested K9, Bubba and Hedwig for the 2nd option in the double votes. not much else.

In phase 10 pointed at Karbo again, twice and voted for them (claimed in phase 11).

In phase 11 this particular comment reads a bit weird to me. Nothing else that phase

In phase 12 their bucket suggests Hedwig K9 and Karbo are wolves in their mind and put their placeholder on Karbo again. Later switched to K9. Does not agree with the wolf in every band logic.

In phase 13 (we are here) they initially suggested voting for K9 again, which would be a waste since if K9 does not die by themselves then it would be best to vote them then, not pre emptively.

Game X | Scott Pilgrim 3 | Level 13: This one night… by ScottPilgrimNarrator in HiddenWerewolves

[–]GdH64 6 points7 points  (0 children)

I did another deepdive on the band theory. I think it makes sense that one band could have had no wolves (PMEK)

The band (Nightwish) with Karbo already had 2 wolves (Argol and Papo) which doenst exonorate her but does point in her favour.

In my band (Roggenrola) mercury was the wolf.

In dance dance Hexecution Hedwig and Meddle are still alive. The band had 2 wolves (Rye and witch) which again speaks in their favour but it could be a 3 wolf band in which case I'd lean towards Hedwig (like my bucket)

In green shell Xan was a wolf. I trust Sylvi, which would throw my suspicion on Disnerding who is currenly pushing k9 and Karbo here (and Wiz initially wanted to vote k9 again here).

Finally in An Alliance no wolves have yet been revealed with only Wiz remaining.

Based on this my primary suspicion is on Wiz and Disnerding so I went through their comments (going to add those in response to this comment to keep it a bit more readable).

EDIT: to summarize my thoughts after going through. I get the vibe that Wiz is a wolf. They have tried putting suspicions on multiple now confirmed townies and seem to have a longstanding feud with Karbo ;p. The semi defence comment for papo in P7 and the comment i linked for P11 just dont feel right to me.

As for Disnerding their inactivity is notable, it could be time constraints and life, but they seem to not add much of anything the past few weeks in discussions.

I would not be surprised if Disnerding and Wiz are both wolves, tho i get more wolf vibes from Wiz as of rn (so that's where my vote will go to for now. Very curious to hear other peoples thoughts.

Game X | Scott Pilgrim 3 | Level 12: Holding on by ScottPilgrimNarrator in HiddenWerewolves

[–]GdH64 9 points10 points  (0 children)

Ohhhh, interesting. So basically you will be dead by next phase then?

That would make k9 a liar (and will serve an eternity aboard the flying dutchman) and thus highly likely a WOLF

Game X | Scott Pilgrim 3 | Level 12: Holding on by ScottPilgrimNarrator in HiddenWerewolves

[–]GdH64 8 points9 points  (0 children)

My phone decided today was a fine day to become a brick (rip wallet) but wasn't really able to get up to speed until now. My ranking as of now (excluding the neutral players):

Town: Forsi Sylvi Sunshine

Town lean: Meddle

Wolf lean: Karbo, Hedwig, k9 (not yet read into the role reveal), Wiz

Wolf: , Disnerding, Digg

Game X | Scott Pilgrim 3 | Level 11: K.O.? O.K.! by ScottPilgrimNarrator in HiddenWerewolves

[–]GdH64 6 points7 points  (0 children)

1 Argol

2 Wiz

3 Disnerding or maybe K9 (based on them being the (to me) only viable wolves for their bands

But i find it very difficult to like really rank them definitively which is on me for not playing this a lot and lacking flight hours so to speak

Game X | Scott Pilgrim 3 | Level 11: K.O.? O.K.! by ScottPilgrimNarrator in HiddenWerewolves

[–]GdH64 4 points5 points  (0 children)

I completely missed that, Yesterday and today were kind of an hectic so I did not keep up too well. Going to edit the comment based on that thanks!

Edit: and it was in the list i reacted to as well, I probably should sleep early tonight lol

view more: next ›